Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 6:04 am
That's not what I meant. I'm referencing your post from D1. I'm curious about your justification.
New XKCD Forums
Press F for the old forum.
https://ramenchef.nfshost.com/nxf/
Are we human or are we dancer mafia (game over, Dancers win!)
Page 28 of 89
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 6:05 am
Why are you voting Alli, George?
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 6:07 am
I think he's scum. His post referencing glue as high probability to be town felt off, and don't see a strong justification for him to believe I'm scum. Why would you proxy your vote to him?
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 6:13 am
That's my immediate gut without re-read at the moment. Not confident in Heury being scum.
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 6:14 am
She seemed to have direction going into the night, whereas I did not.
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 12:00 pm
Cynical view thinks the scum team is heury, Madge, and Seven based on the hijinks EOD.
So Seven, when you did your vote, you posted my reads list before it where it can be inferred that's your justification. You trust my reads that much?
So Seven, when you did your vote, you posted my reads list before it where it can be inferred that's your justification. You trust my reads that much?
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 12:04 pm
Nix that last post, it was Mak's. Shows I maybe shouldn't post at 6am on Sundays. 
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 3:46 pm
Oh not Makhaira! That was so unexpectedly unexpected and not foreseen at all!
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 3:48 pm
Wow realizing I haven't played Yugioh Máster Duel in quite some time. Lately been doing RuneScape and slay the Spire.
LolTheallieza wrote: ↑Sun Sep 08, 2024 5:36 am Speaking of which, I have been thinking a lot about this game during the night phase and I think I have a solve that actually makes sense and I feel like explains a lot of why this game has been feeling so off to me. I'll probably take a day or two to assemble my notes and see what else shakes out from the Night, but I will be looking for your feedback when I get there.
VOTE: Thealissa
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 4:22 pm
…heuristically_alone wrote: ↑Sun Sep 08, 2024 3:46 pm Oh not Makhaira! That was so unexpectedly unexpected and not foreseen at all!
@Everyone I highly recommend we eliminate at will rather than wait until the end of day.
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 4:30 pm
George probably did pull one over on me. It’s probably just EGW, Moody, and Heury.
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 4:33 pm
I don't see why you think that.
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 4:36 pm
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 4:57 pm
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 5:02 pm
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 5:08 pm
One of the symptoms of the majority elim rule that I find so gosh darn thrilling!Freddino18 wrote: ↑Sun Sep 08, 2024 4:57 pmSeconded. I missed eight pages of content in four hours, where the next highest amount of content that I missed in one go was two, for missing an entire day.
Vote: Heury
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 6:16 pm
Morning bark!
2. Agree.
1. Please reconsider your thoughts. Your voice is now the strongest in the game.Makhaira wrote: ↑Sun Sep 08, 2024 5:13 am going to be honest not being able to vote is going to dampen my motivation to like hardcore solve this game but I am not going to play against wincon so I will absolutely try to help yall solve with reasonable effort
still mad yalls waffling at EoD cost us the heury elim grrrrrrrrrrrrrr
2. Agree.
Nice “I would have done it this way as scum” post! -1
Noted
Hi handsome! Can you elaborate on this thought?heuristically_alone wrote: ↑Sun Sep 08, 2024 3:46 pm Oh not Makhaira! That was so unexpectedly unexpected and not foreseen at all!
Please elaborate on this too. I don’t follow how this quote from Theallieza alone is scummy enough to warrant a vote, so you must have additional reasons.heuristically_alone wrote: ↑Sun Sep 08, 2024 3:48 pmLolTheallieza wrote: ↑Sun Sep 08, 2024 5:36 am Speaking of which, I have been thinking a lot about this game during the night phase and I think I have a solve that actually makes sense and I feel like explains a lot of why this game has been feeling so off to me. I'll probably take a day or two to assemble my notes and see what else shakes out from the Night, but I will be looking for your feedback when I get there.
VOTE: Thealissa
Good morning Fred! How are you doing with that reads list?Freddino18 wrote: ↑Sun Sep 08, 2024 4:57 pmSeconded. I missed eight pages of content in four hours, where the next highest amount of content that I missed in one go was two, for missing an entire day.
Vote: Heury
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 7:35 pm
Is this treestump ability something people are familiar with and I haven't heard of before?
Any reason you singled out me in particular?Theallieza wrote: ↑Sun Sep 08, 2024 5:21 am Tree stump on you is an odd choice but I guess you're around and confirmed so hopefully that counts for something. I'd suggest we find you a proxy vote. I would suggest somitomi. Any townies who aren't sure where to vote would do well to follow Mak's suggestions.
Why did you expect Alli to need a proxy vote?
What do you mean by this?heuristically_alone wrote: ↑Sun Sep 08, 2024 3:46 pm Oh not Makhaira! That was so unexpectedly unexpected and not foreseen at all!
I personally could do without 6 pages of content happening after I go to bed.
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 8:13 pm
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 8:53 pm
I found a new method, but it exclusively gives scum reads, so anyone not on the list will be town
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Sun Sep 08, 2024 10:57 pm
Vote count 2
2. Wam - 0:
3. Bessie - 0:
4. heuristically_alone - 2: Seven, Freddino18
6. Madge - 0:
7. Seven - 0:
8. Theallieza - 2: EGW, heuristically_alone
9. somitomi - 0:
10. Freddino18 - 0:
11. moody7277 - 0:
12. JC_DADDY25 - 0:
13. EGW - 1: Theallieza
Not voting: Wam, Bessie, Madge, Somitomi, Moody7277, JC_DADDY25,
With 11 alive it takes 6 to eliminate.
Day 2 ends at 12 am on friday September 13th est!
2. Wam - 0:
3. Bessie - 0:
4. heuristically_alone - 2: Seven, Freddino18
6. Madge - 0:
7. Seven - 0:
8. Theallieza - 2: EGW, heuristically_alone
9. somitomi - 0:
10. Freddino18 - 0:
11. moody7277 - 0:
12. JC_DADDY25 - 0:
13. EGW - 1: Theallieza
Not voting: Wam, Bessie, Madge, Somitomi, Moody7277, JC_DADDY25,
With 11 alive it takes 6 to eliminate.
Day 2 ends at 12 am on friday September 13th est!
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Mon Sep 09, 2024 12:04 am
Bessie
Interest in several players seems like she wants to break meta, but I think it's in a good way. She's seemed to settle on a town core with Thea and EGW (but with some notes about the latter) and a scum core with wam and Fred. Rating +2
Spoiler (Show/Hide)
post 1: town lean on Thea from conf post
post 2: nothing in general sticks out about conf posts, town lean somi, Seven sus
post 3: response to EGW about his conf post, didn't like my interpretation of post 1
post 4: says somi wasn't doing anything odd in his conf post, still reads him town lean, correcting heury on him saying she claimed, Madge is Madge
Considering how seriously takes them, this seems like a reasonable amount of time to devote to conf posts, and she moves on after, townie looking
post 5: wants Glue to justify Madge vote, doesn't like Mak's read on EGW, notes Mak pointing out Seven's lack of follow through on solve, wants somi to say how deeply he read, ick about wam's reads, doesn't like somi's take on it, doesn't like Fred getting distracted by mechanics
post 6: dispute over extension with Seven, counterexamples with rules she doesn't like, another ping about my interpretation of post 1, votes extension
post 7: doesn't like wam's explanation of mistakes on his reads post, somi not being subtle with conf post, I finally get close to her interpretation of Thea's conf post, another wam post of the ick type for her, doesn't like Fred's priorities, wants reads from him, doesn't like lurker votes on JC or Glue, scum lean on Fred after refusal to give any kind of reads list, welcomes JC back
post 8: reading wam as scum for his responses about reads list, applauds reads from Fred with expectation for more detail later, but doesn't like him wanting D2 info, reads list with Thea, EGW townie, JC, Fred scum
post 9: doesn't want to vote Glue, notes huery is fluffy, post by post on JC that leads to her scummy view of him
post 10: refutes EGW's read on Madge because Madge is Madge, doesn't like how made his read of her, wants Mak's reaction to Fred being reluctant to post reads, interprets Glue as reading Mak as scum
post 11: doesn't like JC, Fred, or huery, ick about Glue
Here we get into the EOD rush
post 12: T->S list with Thea, EGW town, Fred, huery, wam scum, votes Fred
post 13: no fucks given about EGW's disapproval of her vote
post 14: anyone below somi fair game on T->S list
post 15: switches to huery
post 16: okay with me or wam to elim
post 17: wants JC to vote
post 18: again a not on Glue
Firmness on who she wants to vote for goes along with her profile
D2
post 19: still waiting for Fred's reads list
post 20: tries to encourage Mak to contribute, gets Seven with the same type of post she didn't like wam doing, wants huery to expand on a couple of posts
post 2: nothing in general sticks out about conf posts, town lean somi, Seven sus
post 3: response to EGW about his conf post, didn't like my interpretation of post 1
post 4: says somi wasn't doing anything odd in his conf post, still reads him town lean, correcting heury on him saying she claimed, Madge is Madge
Considering how seriously takes them, this seems like a reasonable amount of time to devote to conf posts, and she moves on after, townie looking
post 5: wants Glue to justify Madge vote, doesn't like Mak's read on EGW, notes Mak pointing out Seven's lack of follow through on solve, wants somi to say how deeply he read, ick about wam's reads, doesn't like somi's take on it, doesn't like Fred getting distracted by mechanics
post 6: dispute over extension with Seven, counterexamples with rules she doesn't like, another ping about my interpretation of post 1, votes extension
post 7: doesn't like wam's explanation of mistakes on his reads post, somi not being subtle with conf post, I finally get close to her interpretation of Thea's conf post, another wam post of the ick type for her, doesn't like Fred's priorities, wants reads from him, doesn't like lurker votes on JC or Glue, scum lean on Fred after refusal to give any kind of reads list, welcomes JC back
post 8: reading wam as scum for his responses about reads list, applauds reads from Fred with expectation for more detail later, but doesn't like him wanting D2 info, reads list with Thea, EGW townie, JC, Fred scum
post 9: doesn't want to vote Glue, notes huery is fluffy, post by post on JC that leads to her scummy view of him
post 10: refutes EGW's read on Madge because Madge is Madge, doesn't like how made his read of her, wants Mak's reaction to Fred being reluctant to post reads, interprets Glue as reading Mak as scum
post 11: doesn't like JC, Fred, or huery, ick about Glue
Here we get into the EOD rush
post 12: T->S list with Thea, EGW town, Fred, huery, wam scum, votes Fred
post 13: no fucks given about EGW's disapproval of her vote
post 14: anyone below somi fair game on T->S list
post 15: switches to huery
post 16: okay with me or wam to elim
post 17: wants JC to vote
post 18: again a not on Glue
Firmness on who she wants to vote for goes along with her profile
D2
post 19: still waiting for Fred's reads list
post 20: tries to encourage Mak to contribute, gets Seven with the same type of post she didn't like wam doing, wants huery to expand on a couple of posts
Interest in several players seems like she wants to break meta, but I think it's in a good way. She's seemed to settle on a town core with Thea and EGW (but with some notes about the latter) and a scum core with wam and Fred. Rating +2
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Mon Sep 09, 2024 12:31 am
Vote: Fred
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Mon Sep 09, 2024 12:46 am
Fred
With the large proportion of fluff and the reluctance to give more than the skeletal reads list in post 36, his star has definitely fallen with me. Rating -1
Vote: Fred
That vote stays until we get that detailed reads list you've been promising for a while now.
Spoiler (Show/Hide)
post 1: RV on EGW for "posting too many words"
post 2: unvotes EGW
post 3: asks me about RVS
post 4: doesn't like EGW RVing him
post 5: wants people to RP more
There's a fine line between going along with the flavor and obfuscating
post 6: seems not to think there's scum, bastard game
post 7: follow on to post 5
post 8: Not on for deadline
post 9: talking to Mak about EGW's RV, activity level, votes EGW
post 10: doesn't like EGW trying to influence him
post 11: still thinking no night elim with ambiguous rules
post 12: fluff
post 13: trying to explain what he says EGW is doing
post 14: points out cult-style games
post 15: fluff
Here's where I did my first read which put him at +1, and in hindsight that may have been generous, but I did say the trend was downward due to the fluff which started popping up later on
post 16: wants to know more about the wam reads post
post 17: reaction to Seven saying EGW wouldn't be elimed
post 18: follow on to post 17
post 19: again not available at EOD
post 20: worried about majority elim even with extension
post 21: wants to ping Glue and vote for him if needed
post 22: votes extension to get Glue to post
post 23: says he can put up reads early D2, describes Rube Goldberg method for generating them
Seriously?!
post 24: no way to shorten process
post 25: fluff
post 26: fluff
post 27: sus of EGW
post 28: fluff
post 29: didn't remember JC is playing, wanted Glue pinged due to votes
Cynical view really doesn't like that
post 30: sympathy for wam's reads list being shaky, promise of reads
post 31: wants Seven to explain posts about EGW
post 32: Seven's read of me weird, doesn't like huery's post
post 33: double post
post 34: reads Madge as town
post 35: fluff
post 36: bit of a reads list with somi, Mak town, Seven and Bessie scum, and some people as insufficient data, votes Seven
post 37: fluff
post 38: wants Bessie elimed
post 39: fluff
post 40: reads me as scummy, but wants more voting
post 41: fluff
post 42: still wants more from Glue
post 43: response to JC about Fred's setup spec
post 44: fluff
post 45: fluff
As he said, he was not on EOD, so missed the flurry.
D2
post 46: agrees with Seven about not waiting for EOD to elim, votes heury
post 47: no progress on reads
post 48: modified method for scum-only list
post 2: unvotes EGW
post 3: asks me about RVS
post 4: doesn't like EGW RVing him
post 5: wants people to RP more
There's a fine line between going along with the flavor and obfuscating
post 6: seems not to think there's scum, bastard game
post 7: follow on to post 5
post 8: Not on for deadline
post 9: talking to Mak about EGW's RV, activity level, votes EGW
post 10: doesn't like EGW trying to influence him
post 11: still thinking no night elim with ambiguous rules
post 12: fluff
post 13: trying to explain what he says EGW is doing
post 14: points out cult-style games
post 15: fluff
Here's where I did my first read which put him at +1, and in hindsight that may have been generous, but I did say the trend was downward due to the fluff which started popping up later on
post 16: wants to know more about the wam reads post
post 17: reaction to Seven saying EGW wouldn't be elimed
post 18: follow on to post 17
post 19: again not available at EOD
post 20: worried about majority elim even with extension
post 21: wants to ping Glue and vote for him if needed
post 22: votes extension to get Glue to post
post 23: says he can put up reads early D2, describes Rube Goldberg method for generating them
Seriously?!
post 24: no way to shorten process
post 25: fluff
post 26: fluff
post 27: sus of EGW
post 28: fluff
post 29: didn't remember JC is playing, wanted Glue pinged due to votes
Cynical view really doesn't like that
post 30: sympathy for wam's reads list being shaky, promise of reads
post 31: wants Seven to explain posts about EGW
post 32: Seven's read of me weird, doesn't like huery's post
post 33: double post
post 34: reads Madge as town
post 35: fluff
post 36: bit of a reads list with somi, Mak town, Seven and Bessie scum, and some people as insufficient data, votes Seven
post 37: fluff
post 38: wants Bessie elimed
post 39: fluff
post 40: reads me as scummy, but wants more voting
post 41: fluff
post 42: still wants more from Glue
post 43: response to JC about Fred's setup spec
post 44: fluff
post 45: fluff
As he said, he was not on EOD, so missed the flurry.
D2
post 46: agrees with Seven about not waiting for EOD to elim, votes heury
post 47: no progress on reads
post 48: modified method for scum-only list
With the large proportion of fluff and the reluctance to give more than the skeletal reads list in post 36, his star has definitely fallen with me. Rating -1
Vote: Fred
That vote stays until we get that detailed reads list you've been promising for a while now.
Re: Are we human or are we dancer mafia (day 2)
Posted: Mon Sep 09, 2024 1:02 am
huery
post 1: likes somi's question about Thea's diagram, thought Bessie was claiming, likes Madge's question about game title
post 2: ick about post 1 formatting
post 3: fluff about Madge
post 4: fluff about game flavor
3 days go by
post 5: reaction to somi's post about lurking heury, reaction to wam about lurking heury, reads with EGW, somi town, Bessie, Thea scum
post 6: town reads Glue for being resigned, doesn't like Thea trying not to have LG meta
post 7: edit to post 6, "I am reading others as more human than myself."
Huh?
post 8: Mak, me, and JC votable
post 9: votes JC
D2
post 10: sarcastic post about Mak being stumped
post 11: fluff with vote on Thea
Still haven't seen anything that makes me want to take heury off votables list. Rating -1.5
post 1: likes somi's question about Thea's diagram, thought Bessie was claiming, likes Madge's question about game title
post 2: ick about post 1 formatting
post 3: fluff about Madge
post 4: fluff about game flavor
3 days go by
post 5: reaction to somi's post about lurking heury, reaction to wam about lurking heury, reads with EGW, somi town, Bessie, Thea scum
post 6: town reads Glue for being resigned, doesn't like Thea trying not to have LG meta
post 7: edit to post 6, "I am reading others as more human than myself."
Huh?
post 8: Mak, me, and JC votable
post 9: votes JC
D2
post 10: sarcastic post about Mak being stumped
post 11: fluff with vote on Thea
Still haven't seen anything that makes me want to take heury off votables list. Rating -1.5