New XKCD Forums

post 1: welcome to patzer and Snide. asks jimbob about his ordering of factions
post 2: doesn't like heury's response to jimbob. town lean me and bf
post 3: discussion with heury over his response to jimbob, more important issue was why heury answered instead of letting bf answer

Totally agree with this

post 4: discussion with heury, Snide's question about jimbob NAI, boomfrog coming at his read from a different direction than LG
post 5: offended for boomfrog about heury's interpretation of bf's read

The last few posts kind of felt like an impromptu mini-gambit between LG and heury that heury failed miserably

post 6: asking patzer and somi for reads, encouraging Snide for content
post 7: pokes heury about inconsistent read, agrees with bf over heury reasoning, likes jimbob playing as SDK
post 8: reaction to patzer's reads list. jimbob used as easily analisable example. question about reads of people pushing heury
post 9: reads list. bf jimbob town, heury patzer scum.

btw, having bessie listed as NullTown scares the crap out of me

post 10: disagrees with Suzaku as to Snide being townie for use of "we" in a post. Snide's "paranoia level" wrong
post 11: incredulous about heury's reads
post 12: wants patzer to explain suspicion of him
post 13: warning about time zone issues
post 14: Snide not expressing previously codified newbie town behavior

Seriously, his quote looks like it comes from a friggin encyclopedia

post 15: response to jimbob about the difference between in person and forum mafia
post 16: underline vote heury, no actual vote forthcoming unless tie
post 17: not voting heury "for reasons"

Encouraging content from Snide and patzer, spreading pressure around, all looks very good

D2
post 18: befuddled by lack of flip
post 19: lack of flips until D3, cascade of flips later, multiple factions complicate TS lists, wants updated reads from Snide, patzer

Score one for Nostradamus!LG

post 20: response to bessie: somi already answered bessie's question, no answer from bessie about his. poking Snide about pressuring patzer for something he did
post 21: double elimination annoying, bickering with bessie re multiple faction complications. question to and weird feeling about patzer
post 22: RL issues

Cynical view here: LG and bessie picking a fight like this is distancing

post 23: doesn't want heury re-elimed D2. heury as AS due to tactics. wam and Snide votable, patzer looks townier
post 24: welcomes 7en

aside: I do remember Peaceful Whale, specifically there was one game where it was a joke that everybody was claiming they had not done something or other to him (don't recall exactly what)

post 25: prefers eliming mafia over AS, doesn't like wam's "stagnant" play
post 26: response to jimbob for more detailed read of his post
post 27: fluff
post 28: reads post. of live players, jimbob bf town, 7en AS, Snide cult, patzer wam scummy

A more nuanced list because he's been paying attention to multiple factions all game

post 29: open call for questions
post 30: asks 7en about her cult!somi theory, response re bessie wanting a different playmate, some 7en reference
post 31: wants patzer to expand her claim, underline vote Snide
post 32: repeats to patzer that eliminating 7en for a flip isn't worth wasting an elim
post 33: unofficial vote count
post 34: alternative interpretaion re patzer, voting deal with bessie, sarcasm from LG about his potentially being culted
post 35: prefers eliming patzer over me
post 36: response to boomfrog about 7en's claim, doesn't matter if 7en is lying can still work around them
post 37: vote check
post 38: wants to know from jimbob who he thinks is the cult as it's really important
post 39: 7en not cult
post 40: correction, 7en not cult leader
post 41&42: last minute vote herding comments

LaserGuy thinking he has 7en well enough pegged that he says we should focus on more dangerous targets is a level of confidence that I find impressive.

D3
post 43: flat why reaction to 7en's kill claim
post 44: thinks she could have used it better
post 45: asks wam about patzer being the AS
post 46: asks somi about his wam read, somi and Snide who they would have killed
post 47: 7en not votable due to mechanics

post 1: RV Sabrar, LaserGuy's reads "early"
post 2: slight correction to post 1
post 3: question's heury's choice of target, no boomgambit NAI, LG being LG, heury following town meta

Silliness seems to be taken a bit farther than usual, such that some players thought it was serious mechanics checking not taken far enough

post 4: poking heury about pretending to be town
post 5: asks heury about his declared non-voting Snide
post 6: half joking reads based on his RV, wants heury to expand his read of Snide
post 7: town lean on somi for pressure voting heury. patzer heury snide scum, bf LG town

Also quoted in this post, bessie's comment confirming my recollection in the analysis on post 3

post 8: read on Snide is based on Snide's reads list as newbie scum
post 9: asks Suzaku why he doesn't read patzer as more strongly scum
post 10: also wants more from him about bessie
post 11: misapprehension of Suzaku's reads vs. TS list postiioning
post 12: questions patzer on activity->towniness, awaits jimbob's case
post 13: violent agreement with LG poking heury, apparently jimbob did a gambit
post 14: reads post. jimbob LG town, bessie neutral, heury patzer snide scum. votes heury
post 15: vote total notice
post 16: fluff
post 17: curious about LG not voting

Some content, diluted a bit by interspersing two or three line posts. interaction mostly with heury, small amount with Suzaku

D2
post 18: patzer hammer accidental. suggests not voting until noon in case of flips
post 19: morning action required by rules, supports mafia uncultable theory
post 20: wants to answer jimbob's question to Snide
post 21: says he left off the sarcasm tag from post 20
post 22: full explanation of the whole reason for unrecruitable mafia
post 23: discussion with bessie re end of D1 antics, wants bf's reads, expand Snide's read of somi
post 24: TS list, substantially same as previous

Given the lack of flips and the solidified groupthink, this is marginally tolerable

post 25: curious about others finding LG less than perfectly townie
post 26: wants bf more involved. accuses bessie of knowing heury was going to be rezzed, votes heury
post 27: pedantic post
post 28: heury rez most likely intentional, done by bessie
post 29: justifies his ideas on mafia having a rez power based of his Chaos game from a while back

As I was in it, I too remember this game, or rather I have flashback to this game. *shudder*

post 30: agrees with LG about double elim, missed Suzaku post about not getting in a post before D1 hammer, asks me about heury not posting
post 31: asks mod about replacing heury
post 32: wondering who would replace into heury's slot
post 33: welcomes 7en, asks her why she shouldn't be elimed
post 34: correction
post 35: asks patzer about "conversion"
post 36: fluff
post 37: spec patzer cult because of being clueless about cult

Seems to me what cult does should be obvious in the name

post 38: asks 7en about post 37
post 39: in response to 7en, auto-rez -> AS, patzer trying to look town, LG had fast reads for non-bessie players, TS list with jimbob LG town, patzer 7en scum, votes patzer
post 40: wants patzer to claim
post 41: refutes patzer on no more rezzes as Suzaku still not flipped
post 42: fluff
post 43: deductions from patzer's "mafia-only" cop, could also been scum!patzer
post 44: patzer risks counterclaim
post 45: unvote
post 46: discussion with jimbob about mafia!patzer claiming cop as part of a ploy to get town cop
post 47: question to patzer about vulnerability to flavor
post 48: telling patzer it's better for town if mafia use up NK on outed cop
post 49: questions me about wanting Snide elim over somi
post 50: looking at votables
post 51: pinged because I apparently favor keeping somi over Snide
post 52: asks me about my read of somi as AS
post 53: wants flip of somi to test me
post 54: present
post 55: how patzer can fake a cop
post 56: agrees with bessie's setup spec
post 57: votes patzer, check cult number morning D3, no vote on moody
post 58: correction to above
post 59: town has rez power else Suzaku filps, mafia rez OP, cult rez OP
post 60: 7en not cult leader
post 61: fluff
post 62: agrees with LG about 7en not being cult
post 63: despite jimbob, patzer confusion about cult put on due to being cult leader
post 64: present
post 65: getting cult recruit also good
post 66: who all wants to elim somi

Expanded interaction to bessie, jimbob, patzer (Cynical View here: interesting how he's interacting with the eventual elim both days). The stream of consciousness posting at the end of day gets a little hard to parse thoroughly

D3
post 67: Asks 7en about shooting boomfrog instead of her elim target of somi, 7en very sus
post 68: patzer truthful except in case of 7en recruit
post 69: survivor!patzer doesn't know LG isn't mafia unlike mafia!patzer
post 70: refuting 7en's PoE that someone in the circle is lying
post 71: asking somi and Snide for thoughts D3
post 72: asks for snap read by somi on patzer, my post-by-post
post 73: asks 7en for sober posting
post 74: wants another cute pic from bessie