Press F for the old forum.
https://ramenchef.nfshost.com/nxf/
Code: Select all
Malware detected in machine of death.png
Malware detected in halloween costume.png
Analyzing...
CUTIES virus encoded in the bit map.
-Impairing logic matrix.
-Amplifying emotion modules.
Initiating countermeasures...
-Scrubbing 30%
...40%
-Error: operation failed
@boomSeven wrote: ↑Sat Oct 07, 2023 5:08 pmWhen did he imply that I was scummy prior to you asking this?
H not M. Newbie New Year. I will compare.boomfrog wrote: ↑Sat Oct 07, 2023 5:37 pmBessie is a dog of principles. Enough principles that they will cause her significant stress when they are in conflict in a situation.Seven wrote: ↑Fri Oct 06, 2023 8:10 pm Fact 1: bessie feels bad about constantly tunneling somi and him being a day 1 elimination
Fact 2: bessie has stated an unwillingness to vote somitomi today due to Fact 1
Argument 1
Premise 1: If bessie is town, Fact 1 would not prevent her from voting somi
Supplementary Premise: If somi is not mafia, mafia-bessie would indeed avoid pushing him Day 1 on the basis of Fact 1.
Conclusion 1: bessie is mafia
--Notes--
Fact 1 has been established prior to this game.
Fact 2 has been established in this game.
Premise 1 is supported by bessie's personality. She values correctness over emotion. Guilt would not be able to prevent her from voting somi if she felt he was scum. It might cause resistance, but not near 0% chance before she has even read/we've gotten into the game.
Premise 2 is provable/falsifiable.
A) For the integrity of the game she must always play to her win condition.
B) For the sake of fairness she doesn't want anyone repeatedly singled out across multiple games.
She feels guilty about the sorc game because B got broken. Even if she helped A she still broke B. Sevens premise #1 presumes bessie principal A over rides B. But bessie wants to do both. And she can do both as town as long as somi isn't proven scum D1 (which we all know is virtually impossible). Bessie has previously advocated keeping a newbie alive even as likely scum with the idea that they would reveal other scum on D2. (It was that game where zen played under a screen name starting with M. And zen was the newbies scum mate. The newbies name included "whale"). Her behavior here is consistent with her town behavior in that game.
And actually. If she were scum there is a decently likely scenario where her principle A would override B which is if her scummate and Somi were the two possible yeets. The fact that she is not even internally considering that scenario means she has no scum buddy this game and is very likely town.
Seven wrote: ↑Sat Oct 07, 2023 5:08 pmWhen did he imply that I was scummy prior to you asking this?
I have no idea... I distinctly remember detecting an inconsistency in EGWs read of Seven but I really thought it was before I asked that question. But I can't find it now and there are very few posts in between so most likely chance is that my memory is wrong. I'm out of time for now but I'll reread later and try to figure out what I was thinking.
Please do. I find it concerning.boomfrog wrote: ↑Sat Oct 07, 2023 5:59 pmI have no idea... I distinctly remember detecting an inconsistency in EGWs read of Seven but I really thought it was before I asked that question. But I can't find it now and there are very few posts in between so most likely chance is that my memory is wrong. I'm out of time for now but I'll reread later and try to figure out what I was thinking.
We are getting close to deadline. Fun play time is over and it's time to get serious. Can you give a town to scum list and a real vote?
Please respond to my previous inquiry.heuristically_alone wrote: ↑Sat Oct 07, 2023 6:05 pm The cake is definitely a lie. As is all that garbage wine.
VOTE: Seven
Do you have more of a reason for this vote than "wine"?heuristically_alone wrote: ↑Sat Oct 07, 2023 6:05 pm The cake is definitely a lie. As is all that garbage wine.
VOTE: Seven
With regard to Mak, I think Adum's post here is highly convincing of Mak town:
AdumbroDeus wrote: ↑Fri Oct 06, 2023 10:40 pm System.out.println("
Yep, it's definitely all Moody's stuff with highlighting and underlining of BF and Bessie.
Which absolutely needs to be explained, they said it's repetition of their names over the normal parameters but doesn't provide any info about the thought process they thing would produce the reputation.
Also found this notable:
Makhaira wrote: ↑Thu Oct 05, 2023 7:18 pm Moody - not getting any sense of authentic scumhunting from this slot, didn't like their opportunistic dogpiling on me after BF's push without even attempting to understand where the disagreement was coming from in stark contrast to adum, point assignment posts feel arbitrary and filleryWe already know Mak is traveling all day, given how Zeniba formatted their post, thinking the readslist was theirs is a very easy mistake to make.Makhaira wrote: ↑Fri Oct 06, 2023 8:31 pmRe: zenibas readlist, from what I understand to actually be her voice, I think her adum analysis is strong. The rest of the reads I find a bit lacking, the blurbs are just summaries of each slots content, no real analysis as to how she arrived at her "point" assignments for each slot so they arent particularly helpful outside of atleast being actual positions on the slots
What's notable is that the thought process and conclusions are extremely similar, but descriptions aren't identical enough to suggest that it's staged.
That suggests a townie mindset because they don't have an incentive to massage the reads for manipulation purposes.
");
Why will you not answer me?
EGW wrote: ↑Sat Oct 07, 2023 8:19 am
It is moving very fast. You know, the second reason why I have been trying to post less is due to this. I realized I was making it harder for everyone else to be able to sort the game. Yet I know that Zen also believes in posting less. I'm not entirely getting the feel that he is trying to restrain himself this game? Also, I'm not entirely sure if the conversation between you and him about the saltiness is very productive. I know that she usually is busy during the week and I personally know that she works a lot, and I know that when she has time to put in the analysis, she will be readable. I think my early read on her was misguided, due to being wrong.
Yeah so I just skimmed bessie's post Day 1 of Newbie New Year and it just proves my point. It was a newbie game and therefore she wanted to avoid voting out a newbie Day 1, yet she was willing to do it for her win con:Seven wrote: ↑Sat Oct 07, 2023 5:56 pmH not M. Newbie New Year. I will compare.boomfrog wrote: ↑Sat Oct 07, 2023 5:37 pmBessie is a dog of principles. Enough principles that they will cause her significant stress when they are in conflict in a situation.Seven wrote: ↑Fri Oct 06, 2023 8:10 pm Fact 1: bessie feels bad about constantly tunneling somi and him being a day 1 elimination
Fact 2: bessie has stated an unwillingness to vote somitomi today due to Fact 1
Argument 1
Premise 1: If bessie is town, Fact 1 would not prevent her from voting somi
Supplementary Premise: If somi is not mafia, mafia-bessie would indeed avoid pushing him Day 1 on the basis of Fact 1.
Conclusion 1: bessie is mafia
--Notes--
Fact 1 has been established prior to this game.
Fact 2 has been established in this game.
Premise 1 is supported by bessie's personality. She values correctness over emotion. Guilt would not be able to prevent her from voting somi if she felt he was scum. It might cause resistance, but not near 0% chance before she has even read/we've gotten into the game.
Premise 2 is provable/falsifiable.
A) For the integrity of the game she must always play to her win condition.
B) For the sake of fairness she doesn't want anyone repeatedly singled out across multiple games.
She feels guilty about the sorc game because B got broken. Even if she helped A she still broke B. Sevens premise #1 presumes bessie principal A over rides B. But bessie wants to do both. And she can do both as town as long as somi isn't proven scum D1 (which we all know is virtually impossible). Bessie has previously advocated keeping a newbie alive even as likely scum with the idea that they would reveal other scum on D2. (It was that game where zen played under a screen name starting with M. And zen was the newbies scum mate. The newbies name included "whale"). Her behavior here is consistent with her town behavior in that game.
And actually. If she were scum there is a decently likely scenario where her principle A would override B which is if her scummate and Somi were the two possible yeets. The fact that she is not even internally considering that scenario means she has no scum buddy this game and is very likely town.
Here is a list of the games archived from the previous site btw:
https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/ ... sp=sharing
@bessie is there a reason why we removed this link in the smashboards directory thread? I couldn't seem to find it there.
I love you too, Peaceful Whale! Please don’t take anything I say as part of this game
personally. Remember that I am my avatar!
Also, this is a newbie game. We will all do the best we can to help you so you can ask us
anything related to general mafia gameplay and we will answer you truthfully, or Suzaku
and wam will smite us from above. But it doesn’t mean you get a free pass. Please take it as
a sign of respect that I am treating you not as a clueless newbie, but as I would treat any
other player.
bessie wrote:Sigh. Probably Peaceful Whale.Sabrar wrote:Hi bessie! Who will you tunnel next?
Yes. It is a reason that I do not wish to post in this thread. But I also do not want to pm you, since it was asked in-game. The answer has absolutely no bearing on this game, and will give no meta insight to any players in this game. I will forward the answer to the mod team, and if they agree, they may forward it to you. If not, the answer can wait until after the game.
Ah, I remember now.bessie wrote: ↑Sat Oct 07, 2023 6:33 pmYes. It is a reason that I do not wish to post in this thread. But I also do not want to pm you, since it was asked in-game. The answer has absolutely no bearing on this game, and will give no meta insight to any players in this game. I will forward the answer to the mod team, and if they agree, they may forward it to you. If not, the answer can wait until after the game.
