New XKCD Forums

xX_WakeMeUp1337_Xx wrote: ↑Tue Nov 23, 2021 12:18 am
Hello Jedi, if you are villager, what's your opinion about your wagon, and what's your read on the players voting you?

Wouldn't be the first time I've been mislynched fairly early, but I honestly wasn't particularly expecting day 1

I still think math is likely town, still suspicious of sabrar, perhaps a little more suspicious than I had been of morgan and worst

bessie wrote: ↑Tue Nov 23, 2021 2:46 am Hi SuperJedi. You’re here and following the thread; do you have any reads?

Well I'm trying to follow anyway

Was leaning town on seven, now I'm a little less convinced

MathBlade
moody
madge
Wam
Wake
bessie
Seven
the worst
Morgan
Suzaku
Wisp
Sabrar


I think that's everyone?

convinced based off what?

@Seven
@Wisp

What do you think of a MathBlade/Sabrar team?

Seven wrote: ↑Tue Nov 23, 2021 2:40 am And what do you make of it in terms of his alignment?

Nothing. It's bad idea, it doesn't make Wisp scum.

People can change their minds, but I don't see how anyone could believe Wisp was joking about the town-core post.

Why? People do gambits all the time, not that I'm a big fan.

bessie wrote: ↑Tue Nov 23, 2021 2:46 am So is it more important to you to catch scum or to use your power?

This is a misleading question with what you are implying. Catching scum is more important but why can't I do both at the same time?

SuperJedi224 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 23, 2021 4:31 am

xX_WakeMeUp1337_Xx wrote: ↑Tue Nov 23, 2021 12:18 am
Hello Jedi, if you are villager, what's your opinion about your wagon, and what's your read on the players voting you?

Wouldn't be the first time I've been mislynched fairly early, but I honestly wasn't particularly expecting day 1

I still think math is likely town, still suspicious of sabrar, perhaps a little more suspicious than I had been of morgan and worst

That's interesting, talk to me about morgan and the worst

I have a big problem with the worst's acceptance of Wisp's town claim in page one and I wish to know an opinion from somone who read more than me from the game

bessie wrote: ↑Tue Nov 23, 2021 3:46 am

Wisp wrote: ↑Tue Nov 23, 2021 3:33 am what theory? that the team is Seven/Wake/Jedi?
I'd like to think my ability to read Wake is really good, but sure if u want to add more points against me, do your thing I guess

Interesting.

You know how you said that I beat you twice as mafia? In one of those games, I replaced WakeMeUp.

I shamefully have to say I didn't read that game almost at all, i was really busy IRL

You bring up what I bolded, but ftr if a mate would be so close to death the last thing i would do as mafia would be to connect myself with them by an open defence.
And applying a simple logic, i don't know Jedi's alignament but a stale wagon is usually a bad sign iykwim

_______


@everyone if Jedi flips mafia what's happening, if Jedi flips town what's happening?
Where do you look next in both of these worlds?

xX_WakeMeUp1337_Xx wrote: ↑Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:30 am You bring up what I bolded, but ftr if a mate would be so close to death the last thing i would do as mafia would be to connect myself with them by an open defence.
And applying a simple logic, i don't know Jedi's alignament but a stale wagon is usually a bad sign iykwim

_______


@everyone if Jedi flips mafia what's happening, if Jedi flips town what's happening?
Where do you look next in both of these worlds?

Haha you know what pings me even more than claiming on Day 1? It's "would I do this as scum??" posts.

If SuperJedi flips mafia, it's you and Seven,
If Jedi flips town, it's Sabrar and MathBlade.

xX_WakeMeUp1337_Xx wrote: ↑Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:30 am @everyone if Jedi flips mafia what's happening, if Jedi flips town what's happening?
Where do you look next in both of these worlds?

This is premature as a) we might not yeet Jedi, b) there will probably be an NK which would give info and c) we might have results after tonight.

bessie wrote: ↑Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:36 am If Jedi flips town, it's Sabrar and MathBlade.

My disappointment is immeasurable.

bessie wrote: ↑Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:36 am

xX_WakeMeUp1337_Xx wrote: ↑Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:30 am You bring up what I bolded, but ftr if a mate would be so close to death the last thing i would do as mafia would be to connect myself with them by an open defence.
And applying a simple logic, i don't know Jedi's alignament but a stale wagon is usually a bad sign iykwim

_______


@everyone if Jedi flips mafia what's happening, if Jedi flips town what's happening?
Where do you look next in both of these worlds?

Haha you know what pings me even more than claiming on Day 1? It's "would I do this as scum??" posts.

If SuperJedi flips mafia, it's you and Seven,
If Jedi flips town, it's Sabrar and MathBlade.

That's the kind of NAI posts everyone makes from time to time, so that's not a reason to form a read, I thought you know that much

Please give me your reads for the rest of people

Why do you make these associations?
I mean i get, level zero says if the player I defended flips scum that gives you a suspicion on me, but your thought process lacks deepness , and this is noted.

If you have cases for Sabrar and MathBlade please link them to me
What do you think about the worst?

Votecount

Votee (Votes/Elimination) - Voter(s)
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

SuperJedi224 (6/8) - Morgan, Wam, madge, the worst, Sabrar, MathBlade
moody7277 (2/8) - Suzaku, Wisp
Wisp (2/8) - moody7277, Seven
Suzaku (1/8) - SuperJedi224

Not Voting (2): bessie, xX_WakeMeUp1337_Xx

Elimination Deadline is 10 AM PST on November 23rd.

Suzaku is V/LA through Tuesday.

Activity Check 1.5

Wisp - 21
SuperJedi224 - 2
Sabrar - 3
the worst - 3
Morgan - 5
Seven - 8
moody7277 - 5
MathBlade - 6
madge - 1
bessie - 3
Wam - 2

Fifth 24 hours Cutoff

I think Jedi is scum please flip them.

Blatant prod dodge long work shift. Will be long tomorrow. Will try to post by the am but no promises.

I'll try and check in again before I go to bed but I won't be here at deadline.

@Bessie: why aren't you voting? if you were voting who would it be for?

the voters I'm trusting today are Bessie, Seven, and Wisp.

Wisp: votes Moody but supports Jedi vote too.

Seven: votes wisp.

Bessie: no vote. says scum!jedi = wake/7 scum, town!jedi = sabrar/mathblade scum; claims team is [SuperJedi, Zeniba, and patzer]

Kind of all over the place, makes it hard to put my finger down, especially as bessie isn't being clear by voting. It appears both bessie and wisp support the jedi wagon, so I'm content with my vote where it is now.

I should be around at deadline but maybe driving. Given the lack of any counter wagon though I'm not expecting much movement.

Maybe the stale wagon means something, but that doesn't make jedi's slot any better, especially coming from a person who states, "I usually get mislynched a lot, just not on day 1. It feels more like a when does it happen at this point, regardless of his alignment. Just go from there, like it's not worth the time to think about what alignment a slot like Jedi is, because they don't play in a way that shows they are playing to achieve a win con. At least that's my take on the matter. I can probably argue some other people in this game feel like robots as well

bessie wrote: ↑Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:05 am @Seven
@Wisp

What do you think of a MathBlade/Sabrar team?

I can't even remember a mathblade post off the top of my head, and Sabrar makes nice posts, but that's pretty much all he has in my opinion, nice posts. and Sab has had some weird tonal jumps in regards to certain players, like when Morgan talked about Seven's read on me and he went out of his way too make 4 points on the subject. It just felt out of place

so my answer is, there is no reason why it can't be a possibility

Why in particular did you pull out these two people though?

@Michelle
I don't particularly understand why you are so attached to Ducks RVS posts, wont deny that wolves tend to be at their weakest at start of game, but contextually why does it ping u so much, to feel the need to keep bringing it up?

Wam wrote: ↑Fri Nov 19, 2021 8:43 am

Wisp wrote: ↑Thu Nov 18, 2021 7:27 pm @suzaku
How common is it for you to make a read list like that, relatively early into the game?

From gut I wouldnt say it's out of the ordinary

unvote

vote bessie

remind me why u randomly dropped this vote on Bessie on page 4

I need to head to work, if im alive tomorrow, I'll probably start doing things
but IDK if I will be

I willbe around to make sure I can vote to kill a wagon, as long as the wagon isn't a drastic change from what I would like to see dead

Wisp wrote: ↑Tue Nov 23, 2021 11:47 am Sab has had some weird tonal jumps in regards to certain players, like when Morgan talked about Seven's read on me and he went out of his way too make 4 points on the subject. It just felt out of place

If you're talking about this, the second part was a reply to Seven who asked me to comment on his case on you. That case had 4 reasons, that's what you see listed out. My comment to Morgan is disjoint from that.

Have a dentist appointment soon, should be back maybe half an hour before deadline.

Meta reasons bessie used to be much more aggressive and omgus ish when town than scum. Dont know if it still holds but her response was town meta to me.

Reason I don't know if it holds is I have mentioned it to bessie in other games so she maybe able to fake it these days.

Ebwop when voted as town than scum.

Don't remember exactly when I was voted out in the texas holdem one, but I think it was like day two or three?

Town: Morgan
Probably town: bessie, WMU, MathBlade, Seven, madge, Wisp
Dig into on Day 2: moody, Suzaku, Sabrar, the worst, Wam
Not town enough: Jedi

Man, having a Day 1 that’s less than 1000 posts is godly. Why doesn’t everyone play like this.

I am on my phone and in bed, just posting to say nothing has changed for me and I am looking forward to d2 and havi something to go on.

Goodnight, all!

Bessie trending down.