New XKCD Forums

Scum candidates: Heury (80% scum per Sabrar's math), Prince J (per EGW's last post, sheeping a dead townie).

Neutral providing good content: Fred, Bessie, Sabrar
Neutral not providing good content: ∅

Town: somi due to lack of CC

Nobody has acted especially suspicious today, my gutreads are all I go on plus sheeping dead townies. Given EGW picked Heury as scum, I feel pretty good about Prince J being the next candidate based on the information I have at the moment.

I also understand that one of Fred, Bessie, Sabrar has to be scum (assuming we take somi as conftown for the purpose of discussion). I don't have any idea which to be honest, but if I had to guess I'd come down on Bessie, but it's like a 40/30/30 thing and I would want to see what Heury and Prince J flip as beforehand so I could look over interactions/etc. The reason for coming down on Bessie is her content feels slightly different to normal? If that makes sense? Like the vibe is a little different.

If I had to pick next I'd go Sabrar as second scummiest with Fred as towniest. And I'm pretty aware that I have nothing to go on with Fred and my only gutreads are based on people acting "strange" or whatever

so here's my ordering:

Town
Somi
----
Fred
Sabrar
Bessie
----
Prince J
Heury
Scum

Damn bessie, did you just get Madge to make a reads list??????

(also I'm *obviously* aware that Prince J and Huery could both flip town and that my post doesn't account for that)

also i won't be online for deadline, i'll be online maybe 3-4 hours before.

Votes

Prince J (1): bessie

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to eliminate.

Prince J has been prodded.

Tbh, I'm being so lazy until Heury flips atm.

I would wanna do reads, but I'm just meh.

*pinky promise for a better D3 comparatively to my dumpster D2 and more closer to D1*

I have severely put this game on the backburner, yet my pressure has only become more due to EQW late suspicion of me while also them dying which tbh I wouldn't kill Ran here.

Though that's just my personal headspace, but yeah.

If you are asking for reads, they are honestly TBD, after this phase so if you would like more in-depth, I sincerely apologize, yet I must decline engaging that currently.

Prince J wrote: ↑Fri Mar 24, 2023 3:50 amIf you are asking for reads, they are honestly TBD, after this phase so if you would like more in-depth, I sincerely apologize, yet I must decline engaging that currently.

Well that's not fair (I'm just bellyaching about my D1 reads)

yeah, it's not fair at all. i don't want to vote you out tomorrow because i'm mad at you, prince J, but it might be where my brain ends up. ughhh

bessie wrote: ↑Fri Mar 24, 2023 2:42 am Would you vote for Sabrar? If not, for whom do you plan on voting today?

I would gladly vote sabrar today, though preference is Madge. I think it's more important to hit mafia today.

Prince J wrote: ↑Fri Mar 24, 2023 3:45 am Tbh, I'm being so lazy until Heury flips atm.

I would wanna do reads, but I'm just meh

Gross.

I really need to do a re-read of the game when my work week is over. While my read prince j has primary been due to nothing scummy in the content (until now at least) but there's just not sufficient content to warrant a town read.

bessie wrote: ↑Fri Mar 24, 2023 1:58 am Is this offer available only to Sabrar or can we all get in on it??

Sorry, exclusive offer. Besides, you had your turn already

Prince J wrote: ↑Fri Mar 24, 2023 3:50 am I have severely put this game on the backburner, yet my pressure has only become more due to EQW late suspicion of me while also them dying which tbh I wouldn't kill Ran here.

Oh hey, an actual "would I do this as scum" post.

Prince J wrote: ↑Fri Mar 24, 2023 3:50 am If you are asking for reads, they are honestly TBD, after this phase so if you would like more in-depth, I sincerely apologize, yet I must decline engaging that currently.

It doesn't have to be in-depth, but surely you have some impression of people by now?

@Sabrar: where is your head right now?

somitomi wrote: ↑Fri Mar 24, 2023 9:31 am@Sabrar: where is your head right now?

Prince J's lazyness reinforces my suspicion about the scum-team giving up, also poe points in that direction. I have an interesting theory why Madge could be the Millerizer after all but I I think we should discuss that D3.

bessie wrote: ↑Fri Mar 24, 2023 1:58 amIma gonna imitate Prince J try this out.

Vote: Prince J

I wish you good luck in your endeavor, I would join but there is too little time left in the day.

Vote: heury

Heury's definitely the play today, but my paranoia-brain is starting to freak and I'm less and less sure about Prince. I mean come on, would mafia really give up when I dropped the ball this hard and there's basically no D2 interactions between them and Heury that we could analyse? From what I gathered, Prince isn't new to mafia and the rest of you lot are definitely good enough to do this. I know I've had worse starts as mafia and I kept going for as long as I could (which was surprisingly long).

I want to vote Heury nowish but don't want to pull a somi so let me do a quick count

Unofficial Votes

Prince J (1): bessie
Heury (3): Prince J, Sabrar, Madge

4 to hammer

Vote Heury

Heury is now at E-1

Hi! Did anybody miss me me me?

madge wrote: ↑Fri Mar 24, 2023 2:55 am Damn bessie, did you just get Madge to make a reads list??????

How unlike you. I wonder why you are actually trying in this game.

Prince J wrote: ↑Fri Mar 24, 2023 3:50 am I have severely put this game on the backburner, yet my pressure has only become more due to EQW late suspicion of me while also them dying which tbh I wouldn't kill Ran here.

Yeah I wouldn’t do that if I were scum either.

Prince J wrote: ↑Fri Mar 24, 2023 3:50 am If you are asking for reads, they are honestly TBD, after this phase so if you would like more in-depth, I sincerely apologize, yet I must decline engaging that currently.

I don’t need anything in depth. How about a town-scum list?

heuristically_alone wrote: ↑Fri Mar 24, 2023 9:04 am I would gladly vote sabrar today, though preference is Madge. I think it's more important to hit mafia today.

Sabrar is in your bottom two. If you don’t think Sabrar is mafia, who is? If you’re going to place a vote you have about three hours. Unless Fred hammers.

somitomi wrote: ↑Fri Mar 24, 2023 10:15 pm Heury's definitely the play today, but my paranoia-brain is starting to freak and I'm less and less sure about Prince. I mean come on, would mafia really give up when I dropped the ball this hard and there's basically no D2 interactions between them and Heury that we could analyse? From what I gathered, Prince isn't new to mafia and the rest of you lot are definitely good enough to do this. I know I've had worse starts as mafia and I kept going for as long as I could (which was surprisingly long).

PRINCE J IS MAFIA I PICKED MY HILL!!!

Woof
Court
EGW
bessie
somitomi
NEUTRAL LINE
Fred
INDIE LINE
Madge
Sabrar
MAFIA LINE
heuristically_alone
Prince J
Grr

Deadline is in roughly 2 and a half hours!

https://youtu.be/bV0RAcuG2Ao

^Me and Somi’s characters from Stranger Things Mafia duking it out to Running Up That Hill (Stranger Things spoilers)

So where is everybody??

Lonely puppy!

I'm fairly certain Madge is mafia. I think either Sabrar or Bessie is the millerizer. If Bessie is not millerizer she is likely town. If Sabrar is not millerizer he is likely the other mafia. At the end d1 I was playing with the idea of Bessie as Madge's scum partner but right now I think that's less than likely. And now more than ever she's been following her town meta. That leaves either Fred or prince that could be scum partners with Madge and I'm less and less confident about prince.

Vote: Prince J

bessie wrote: ↑Sat Mar 25, 2023 2:51 am Lonely puppy!

the dog with the foolish grin is keeping perfectly still.PNG

Don't be lonely. I'm here! Granted I'm at work but this is more important.

Woof woof woof!

Bark bark!