New XKCD Forums

Alright sorry for delay, time to catch up.

Starting with my last post,

patzer wrote: ↑Fri Nov 19, 2021 1:31 pm Hm. Nothing strongly jumped out at me but might as well go through player list and see what I think.

Players from OP:

1. Suzaku
2. moody7277
3. madge
4. Zeniba
5. Wam
6. bessie
7. patzer
8. SuperJedi224
9. the worst
10. Morgan
11. Wisp
12. Sabrar
13. MathBlade

Suzaku: three posts. First is a random vote, second post is very weak stuff on all (understandably), only notable thing is accusing Wisp of “active lurking” but thinks that seems to be more of a culture difference. Nothing much to go on with him, neutral.

Moody: First post of content is targeting Wisp. Fairly similar reasons to Suzaku’s targeting. Will get back to thoughts on this once I’ve done my read on Wisp. Also disapproves of Bessie wagon- will have opinion more once I’ve read though Bessie’s posts.

Madge: alright she seems legit, like I haven’t played with her before but he playstyle seems to match, that being said it’d be fairly easy for mafia to emulate that

Zeniba: No posts. away doing irl stuff, it seems. obvious neutral nvm Seven took over. Seven: instantly scumread Wisp. Typical Seven behaviour, they’ve often got a good eye for stuff. Town if Wisp is scum, as the only other theory- intentional deflection- is just an unnecessary gamble. Honestly I have town vibes anyway but idk if that’s just overcompensation for last time’s mistaken scumread


Wam: Doesn’t seem to have said much meaningful so far, neutral

Bessie: started off with a very abrasive post tone. town points for that bc no reason for scum to poke their neck out like that, I don’t remember bessie being so much like that as AS last time. whole style seems to confirm this. lean town

superjedi: tried to make a read list, fair enough. content but not a lot of meaningful content. the sort of thing I’d do tbh. Really don’t think there are any signs either way. neutral

the worst: started with a random vote and questioning Morgan. generally curious. no real signs here either, neutral

Morgan: omg Morgan has a lot of posts. Started with doubting Wisp being scum, upon which Wisp said he had had this play style as scum. Thinks Seven had a bad entrance but that feels like culture clash. Really hard to say for sure but I’ll give a few town points for not staying under the radar

Wisp: SEVENTY-NINE POSTS. what the. I don’t know how to summarize this but there’s certainly some content. I don’tnknow if this is normal based on his meta?

Sabrar: Seven is suspicious of him, interestingly enough. He feels fairly honest to me but slightly under the radar. I would say lean town but I’ll do a neutral just bc of seven.

MathBlade: a more active player and honest feeling. vague town lean.

alright, nothing to go on, this is expected for D1

question is which yeet would give the most info. Jedi wagon doesn’t make sense to me. Any other ideas?

@sabrar I felt like answering the question why shouldn't I?

Dont like sabrar content so far seems very sitting back and not involed which i remember.

For once I'm not finding seven suspicious which makes a change. I'm sure it will change soon though.

I think jedi is scum due to not wanting to solve as shown by picking just active wagons but it does feel too easy.

bessie wrote:I have reservations about Sabrar, I FoS’d him in my second post. And I am suspicious of SuperJedi. But knowing what you do of Sabrar, do you really think Sabrar lets SuperJedi post the way he has this game?

Dangit, that's where Wisp got the idea I was figuring a Sab-SJ team. That was a typo, the phrase should read "If by some chance Jedi does flip town".

Wisp wrote:the question here isn't, "can Jedi be town", but rather, "Why shouldn't he die today?"

No reason that I can see. I am perfectly happy with the Jedi-wagon.

Ya this game is going to be fun to solve at this rate...

Wisp wrote: ↑Mon Nov 22, 2021 2:31 pm Ya this game is going to be fun to solve at this rate...

Aren't they all?

I meant mostly on levels of content, it's somewhat hard to parse through some of these players based on what their content means for their alignment

The certificate being expired makes me not want to do anymore today, it's hard to reread when I need to force my connection to every new page

I'll try to reread but it's unlikely I change from the PoE of Sabrar/Moody/Jedi atm

Wam wrote: ↑Mon Nov 22, 2021 2:43 pm

Wisp wrote: ↑Mon Nov 22, 2021 2:31 pm Ya this game is going to be fun to solve at this rate...

Aren't they all?

They can be

Wisp wrote: ↑Mon Nov 22, 2021 4:16 pm The certificate being expired makes me not want to do anymore today, it's hard to reread when I need to force my connection to every new page

Switching browsers helps, at least on my end Firefox only makes me do that once and not redo it for every page

I haven’t been able to access the site since last night, so that was fun.

Not really gonna be able to do a meaningful catch-up. I was counting on being able to do it incrementally throughout the morning.

If there’s no compelling reason to move my vote from Jedi, it’s going to stay there.

Lmao a wolf slip, haven't seen one of those in ages
Rip

@wakemeup
I'm gunna do a bit of grandstanding, I think I deserve it
Hi, and sorry you replaced into a wolf slot

Wisp wrote: ↑Mon Nov 22, 2021 6:02 pm Lmao a wolf slip, haven't seen one of those in ages
Rip

?

lol

Just got home.

Oh, there’s an extension. I didn’t get to read most of page ten.

Wisp, what are you talking about.

Nothing, don't worry about it, wolves can kill me tonight

Boring.

If WMUslot slipped, then Jedi is still their partner. Hooray.

Could everyone state their opinion of wisp and my wisp case in their next post. Especially @Sabrar @theworst @morgan and @mathblade.

The wisp case for reference.

My original read of Seven was correct too, sadness, this is why I dislike real time

The case doesn't do anything for me. If anything, your case looks spun to come to a pre-determined conclusion.

But Wisp says you're town, so oh well.

MathBlade wrote: ↑Thu Nov 18, 2021 1:50 am

Wisp wrote: ↑Wed Nov 17, 2021 11:25 pm 3. madge
5. Wam

6. bessie
9. the worst
Sabrar


so i know for a fact i played with the bottom 3, I think I played with the top two?
if Im missing anyone, sorry

also whats with all the smash players on this site?

You have me at a disadvantage. I have played waaaay too much mafia and do not remember you.

Why did you say this if wisp didn't mention you?

MathBlade wrote: ↑Fri Nov 19, 2021 5:44 am Hmmm I don’t like the Bessie wagon given it seems to rely on Suzaku scum and Suzaku isn’t flipped so we don’t know if the premise is true.

How did it rely on the premise that Suzaku is scum?

Wisp wrote: ↑Mon Nov 22, 2021 6:06 pm @wakemeup
I'm gunna do a bit of grandstanding, I think I deserve it
Hi, and sorry you replaced into a wolf slot

I had a huge work day until one moment (2 hours ago) when i came home and I watched TV (forgot to check this thread, i waited for my first post to receive approval)

Now you will excuse me, I have to read

Btw, slow down with the bolded type of sentences, you sound condescendent and show lack of concern about my alignament tbh

Wisp wrote: ↑Mon Nov 22, 2021 6:02 pm Lmao a wolf slip, haven't seen one of those in ages
Rip

Explain