New XKCD Forums

Freddino18 wrote: ↑Sun Sep 22, 2024 4:08 pm

Theallieza wrote: ↑Wed Sep 18, 2024 3:47 am Quick mostly-distracted thoughts:

I feel like JC is probably Town here. His play just feels so disconnected from everyone else it's really hard for me to believe he is actually paired with someone.

Santy is kind of a toss-up for me. I really like their content D3 and they come across as very authentic. OTOH, I am reasonably certain that they are a far better player than I am and I think there's a decent chance they could snow me easily. I still find Somi's play to be quite scummy. Though if Seven is Town I am somewhat less inclined to believe in scum!somi.

Which leaves the scum team as moody, bessie, and I guess Madge? I have higher confidence in Fred's townslip than Madge's and bessie is very unlikely to push Fred the way that she has as a teammate.

My investigation keeps coming back to here. Someone help me dig? Thea, what's with the soft 180 on Madge?

Just working through possible PoE. I think those reads are probably wrong. If my reads were good, I'd be dead instead of Seven.

I don't think Madge is scum... The townslip on her I think is strong and I don't have specific problems with her play.

I think scum Madge would have fought harder to protect Bessie. She thinks Bessie is a very strong player and Madge probably would be hoping she'd carry the game.

If JC is Town I will be very surprised.

Santy is a very strong player and I think his play has been solid, but PoE points to him and somi was scummy. Seven kill also implicates Santy as well IMHO.

Vote Santy

Happy with either him or JC. Not interested in anyone else until we see a town flip from either of these two

That works for me, but if I end up voted today I'm pointed at Madge.

Unvote

Vote: Santy

That's L-1

oh shit

temporary unvote

Unvote

There, more clear

As funny as it would be to have a hammer in the first 24 hours, imma say we wait for the people who haven't shown up lol

Freddino18 wrote: ↑Sun Sep 22, 2024 7:57 pm As funny as it would be to have a hammer in the first 24 hours, imma say we wait for the people who haven't shown up lol

That's why I said tomorrow morning my time was when I'm planning on voting, because there seems to be a crap-ton of posting that happens in the wee hours my time.

Hell yeah. Do you have an approximate number of hours until then?

Freddino18 wrote: ↑Sun Sep 22, 2024 8:12 pm Hell yeah. Do you have an approximate number of hours until then?

15 1/2 hours, give or take 5 minutes.

I will not be awake for your hammer

Freddino18 wrote: ↑Sun Sep 22, 2024 8:23 pm I will not be awake for your hammer

It'd only be a hammer if you put your vote on Santy prior to bed and no-one else votes them before ~7am my time.

Close enough

Wam wrote: ↑Sun Sep 22, 2024 6:58 pm Fred I like your analysis but I have been thinking about it and I think only santy, Thea or me kills seven overnight.

I'm town I ahve a clear on Thea so must be santy.

Reasons:

1) seven only player with experience playing with santy
2) Ignoring the cop and using the RBer is an experienced scum player which takes out JC and Fred
3) Been scum reading somi sant as Fred has neatly summarised
4) Think madfe would have gone Thea over seven if they were shooting a townie with result

vote santy

for the record this is a very sane take and makes me less suspicious that wam could be deepwolfing here by selling the scum comp and giving out free clears to buy a ticket to endgame. Not impossible though and should be held in mind incase we end up in weird endgame

JC CANNOT GO TO ENDGAME THOUGH EVER

I do think though that Seven's dying push for santy should be honored with seven flipping town. Seven hardread scum bessie, have to give credit where credit is due, Seven's scumdar was on point last phase. scum!santy in endgame also seems like a menace so yeah both JC and santy elims are both valid and come with diff benefits

Still doing my re-read but I really do think those two are locked in as the play today barring me having some fucking eureka moment or some shit

also for the record wams post deepens may paranoia about a possible bessie/wam/thea team who saw the PoE net closing and needed to radically alter the landscape with a bessie sacrifice if they legit were afraid seven was about to full solve

this mean wam would more likely than not have to be scum VT cop because I don't think scum wam risks counterclaiming seven like that, wam I think had to know for sure Seven was VT

don't let my paranoia distract anyone though these are mostly notes to myself for deeper in lategame, my current assessment is the mates are within JC, Somi/santy, moody and JC and Santy are far and away the best plays today

Re: Santy: Yeah, I just decided not to quote that one.

Is everyone else waiting for content? It's been nearly 6 hours.

Freddino18 wrote: ↑Mon Sep 23, 2024 2:48 am Is everyone else waiting for content? It's been nearly 6 hours.

I did have dnd session today and just relaxed a bit afterwards not going to lie.

Skimmed a bit and saw people voting me but its a problem for tomorrow me . Being in this spot kinda sucks because there isnt much I could do about somi (and not that I see much talked about anyways) and the nka is big bunch of poop wifom . But elaborating on that is just going to waste time so bweh.

Better to slap some sense into thread with actual arguments and casing rather than defending is what I think. But feng shui needs to ve clear so I dont get stuck on pettyness about people being wrong on me

Wam vote on me I think is the mlre hedious one btw. Fred even though I skimmed and didnt read fully felt like he us caring and has more belief and with more nuance idk.

And im doing what K said I didnt wanna do smh smh.
Gn thread

nini

guess Imma enable hammer

Vote: Santy

(weird thing, predictive text saw sant and decided to complete it as santiago[/b] with the bold end tag)

Santygrass wrote: ↑Mon Sep 23, 2024 3:37 am Wam vote on me I think is the mlre hedious one btw. Fred even though I skimmed and didnt read fully felt like he us caring and has more belief and with more nuance idk.

And im doing what K said I didnt wanna do smh smh.
Gn thread

Nice omgus

What does that mean, brain keeps trying to say amongus