New XKCD Forums

EGW wrote: ↑Sat Feb 01, 2025 6:44 am Well I targeted Mak and was going to hope he turned out to be a liar, and considered Santy as likely busser for Wam. Never mind on that though.

Like, I wrote in my legacy how Wam flipping scum clearedpeople, pinged you directly on who was the best target for your flavor cop , and you continuing to trip so hard EGW is just... Rough to deal with.

Im going to sleep (its almost 6am wheeee) but if you are town please redeem yourself today idk like please consider others reads and dont solve into your own confbias bubble because if you are town your solbing has been constant nitpicking and working on baseless stuff, trying to fit what happened in thread along with your solve and ignoring aand sussing everything that didnt fit. You made some changes but it was literally changing one name for other and just keep tunneling .

And look what results you got. I believe town you can do better. Sorry if I sound rough here maybe its the lack of sleep. But I want to believe in you, and like try to *work together* instead of feeling like all the work and attempts I did to work together were completely ignored like they were the previous day

Santygrass wrote: ↑Sat Feb 01, 2025 8:43 am And Boomfrog like, proposed the idea that got Wam outed aswell

I agree that Heury and Boomfrog are unlikely to be mafia based on this. I'll have to mull over what this means for Sabrar

Also, speaking of that:
@philip: please claim whether you're Zestiria or Berseria and if you're aligned with a Lord of Calamity

Sabrar wrote: ↑Sat Feb 01, 2025 8:28 am

Sabrar wrote: ↑Sat Feb 01, 2025 7:59 am Is it part of your role that the kill is published? If not, why did you presume that you would need to claim D3?

Could you also answer this one?

I didn't know it would be published as a devour instead of a kill. Role only states that it outprioritizes a standard kill.

But I thought there was a good chance of scum figuring out I was the big with me having claimed Therion so wanted to claim after getting my first night chat.

That's why EGW is my top scum read. For you or Boomfrog to be scum there's more bussing then I'd be brave enough to commit to.

wam is known to be open to bussing, see Animal Kingdom for example.

heuristically_alone wrote: ↑Sat Feb 01, 2025 8:53 am I didn't know it would be published as a devour instead of a kill. Role only states that it outprioritizes a standard kill.

But the mod publicly stating that it was you who killed madge is part of your role?

Santygrass wrote: ↑Sat Feb 01, 2025 8:49 amAnd look what results you got. I believe town you can do better. Sorry if I sound rough here maybe its the lack of sleep. But I want to believe in you, and like try to *work together* instead of feeling like all the work and attempts I did to work together were completely ignored like they were the previous day

I was way, way off. I was surprised to see Madge flip scum. Now I'm totally unsure how to go beyond here at this point. Yet I'll take tomorrow to re-read and gather my thoughts. Seeing the flips makes me more comfortable with you as a townie read.

heuristically_alone wrote: ↑Sat Feb 01, 2025 8:19 amShe can't believe EGW would make that mistake and then wonders if Sabrar will point it out and then yes finds the post of Sabrar pointing it out and EGW never replies back. EGW -1

Yet I also posted her expansion in my previous post to that. So I'm not sure what the mistake is if I posted both of her posts.

So Heury is the Devourer, cool.

Curious, why was the kill on Madge published, but the one on Bessie was not?

Sabrar wrote:Is it part of your role that the kill is published? If not, why did you presume that you would need to claim D3?

Actually, I'm the one who talked Madge into doing that.

So much egg. All over. Going to need a towel.

moody7277 wrote: ↑Sat Feb 01, 2025 11:04 am

Sabrar wrote:Is it part of your role that the kill is published? If not, why did you presume that you would need to claim D3?

Actually, I'm the one who talked Madge into doing that.

So much egg. All over. Going to need a towel.

You're saying madge had an active ability that would make her death loud?

I'm saying she had a loudener ability that I told her she should use on heury because I thought he'd be the one to do the NK. Right for the wrong reason here.

moody7277 wrote: ↑Sat Feb 01, 2025 11:04 am Actually, I'm the one who talked Madge into doing that.

At least I got one guess right, yay.

Sabrar wrote: ↑Sat Feb 01, 2025 7:01 am I don't have a night result that provides an immediate solution. Do people want me to claim right now, or do we wait for others, e.g. heury. Also do we suppose that the malevolence mafia is entirely gone?

I trust you are town 99%. I don't want you to claim for any defensive reasons, but claim any info that is useful for town.

Also, called it on madge faking Miller!

@moody did madge claim any other powers? Any summery of her chat would help with finding her allies. I assume there's one more in her mafia left. But it may be 2 more? Which feels crazy with how town everyone is.

11-4
8-4
7-2

Yeah game balance wise there should be 2 more mafia if it's not multiball.

But for the sake of due diligence, @sabrar what was your town read of madge from?

She said she had a RB and a Compulsor, which would have required someone to use their power.

boomfrog wrote: ↑Sat Feb 01, 2025 1:32 pm But for the sake of due diligence, @sabrar what was your town read of madge from?

I guessed that moody targeted her and thought she was Tracker.

Sabrar wrote: ↑Sat Feb 01, 2025 1:57 pm

boomfrog wrote: ↑Sat Feb 01, 2025 1:32 pm But for the sake of due diligence, @sabrar what was your town read of madge from?

I guessed that moody targeted her and thought she was Tracker.

What exactly led you to guess Madge was Moody's target?

moody7277 wrote: ↑Sat Feb 01, 2025 1:38 pm She said she had a RB and a Compulsor, which would have required someone to use their power.

Does it make sense to reveal more about the little birdie that told you Sabrar targeted mak? I thought your only source of extra info was madge?

AdumbroDeus wrote: ↑Sat Feb 01, 2025 8:38 am I am handsome and intelligent.

Modprod Phillip please

@Santy, @Bop: Updated reads?

And Bop, any guess why Mak was targeted with the NE?

i never know what to type for these things. can anyone recommend a good target for my power?

Do not ask much of me yet, Im like so sleeepy ffs I regret staying up so late yesterday . I think PoE is EGW/Sabrar/JC/Somi for me now

For now @moody I want to know all the deets on what Madge told about you, and if she knew how long was the neighborizing and stuff. Cause if she did I think is kinda a good look for JC honestly

phillip1882 wrote: ↑Sat Feb 01, 2025 3:56 pm i never know what to type for these things. can anyone recommend a good target for my power?

That time has passed. We won't have good advice for this until near the end of the Day phase. Who would you trust to give you advice on targeting?

If Im interpreting it correctly, Madge is the one that told you about tracking Sabrar to Mak n1. Did she explain the reasoning of why?