New XKCD Forums

madge wrote: ↑Sun Dec 05, 2021 10:19 pm also RE: mathblade if the vote powers go away at ELo then I'm not so paranoid and we're good

madge wrote: ↑Sun Dec 05, 2021 10:14 pm Guys, unvote. I have an innocent result on the worst (I am not a classic cop obviously and I'd prefer not to go into more detail until tomorrow).

MathBlade wrote: ↑Sun Dec 05, 2021 10:55 pm I already inno’d him?

Seven wrote: ↑Sun Dec 05, 2021 7:16 pm I would like for just your claim @ tw. We don't need a mass claim, you said you could clear jedi today, this implies you were going to out with your info.

Seven wrote: ↑Sun Dec 05, 2021 8:08 pm Alright guys well I wanted to wait for Ducky to out his results and officially clear Jedi but he's not being very forthcoming, so I'll go ahead and move things forward.

So from what I gather, Moody you neighborized Ducky and Madge, correct? Why did you choose those two?

Here is how things are gonna go:
-At this point, I am the only confirmed town (sans strongman, which can somewhat be resolved by MB voting different from me today so that I remain blocked), so we form a town block of towniness around me.

-We are not eliminating WMU. No one has addressed the point about Sabrar trying to convince WMU to vote Jedi (Duck wont even read it). She is town, the rest of you townies really need to trust me on this one.

-We are not eliminating Wam. He catalyzed the Sabrar elimination. Not worth the points considering Sabrar's role. Additionally, scum!Wam could have easily used the gun in a way that benefited scum, Madge even gave him an opening to use his own judgement, but he kept the power in town's hands.

-We are not eliminating Madge. She was too invested/confused about Marlkin's claim for it to have been S/S theater.

This is my town core. @Madge @Wam @WMU I ask of you please, just for today to join hands and lend me your strength. You are all townies, please no more fighting. Just trust me for today.

This leaves: Moody, Jedi, Mathblade, the worst

-Moody's tone is different than in Halloween. He is more go-with-the-flowy. Albeit this could be scum who is tired of being scum two games in a row and losing their strongest scummate day one. However, the way that Moody distinguished his posts from Suzakus when discussing their posting styles day 1 with Wisp seemed non-informed. And based on Sabrar's read list, it also seemed he was dressing up moody for a future miselim.

-Jedi seems like a good possibility to me if it were not for Ducky's claim, hence why the info would be nice. But if he's not going to out it and has ran it by Madge, I guess I will just have to take their word on it. One thing that points to Jedi is Marklin's botched claim. I can't imagine anyone else here would have given the go-ahead on that.

-It doesn't make sense to eliminate Mathblade today because he is our cop and will self-resolve.

-The worst is the absolute best elimination. I've laid out my case for why I think he's scum here. He is not at all cleared because there was another scum alive Night 1 when he was blocked. I think it is between the worst and Jedi, and if Jedi is the worst's inno, that only leaves him.

Vote: the worst

@Madge
@Wam
@WMU
@moody
@jedi

join me

https://youtu.be/OA8wkz0uGLE

the worst wrote: ↑Sun Dec 05, 2021 11:55 pm @mathblade would you mind blocking in this order?
first priority: wmu
second priority: wam
third priority: seven
fourth priority: moody

I have a theory

madge wrote: ↑Sun Dec 05, 2021 11:13 pm My results are certain, the only thing that can mess with them is a 3p, which ducky says we don't have, and even if ducky lies and we *did* have 3p, because of the way my power works I happen to know ducky is not an indie.

@mathblade I checked ducky because they're my neighbour so I wanted to be sure I could trust them, and I don't trust you.

@mathblade also yes i'm paranoid it's why i'm good at this part of the game, where things get tight and we can start using PoE to get things sorted

madge wrote: ↑Sun Dec 05, 2021 10:19 pm also RE: mathblade if the vote powers go away at ELo then I'm not so paranoid and we're good

the worst wrote: ↑Sun Dec 05, 2021 11:33 pm

Seven wrote: ↑Sun Dec 05, 2021 8:08 pm Alright guys well I wanted to wait for Ducky to out his results and officially clear Jedi but he's not being very forthcoming, so I'll go ahead and move things forward.

So from what I gather, Moody you neighborized Ducky and Madge, correct? Why did you choose those two?

Here is how things are gonna go:
-At this point, I am the only confirmed town (sans strongman, which can somewhat be resolved by MB voting different from me today so that I remain blocked), so we form a town block of towniness around me.

-We are not eliminating WMU. No one has addressed the point about Sabrar trying to convince WMU to vote Jedi (Duck wont even read it). She is town, the rest of you townies really need to trust me on this one.

-We are not eliminating Wam. He catalyzed the Sabrar elimination. Not worth the points considering Sabrar's role. Additionally, scum!Wam could have easily used the gun in a way that benefited scum, Madge even gave him an opening to use his own judgement, but he kept the power in town's hands.

-We are not eliminating Madge. She was too invested/confused about Marlkin's claim for it to have been S/S theater.

This is my town core. @Madge @Wam @WMU I ask of you please, just for today to join hands and lend me your strength. You are all townies, please no more fighting. Just trust me for today.

This leaves: Moody, Jedi, Mathblade, the worst

-Moody's tone is different than in Halloween. He is more go-with-the-flowy. Albeit this could be scum who is tired of being scum two games in a row and losing their strongest scummate day one. However, the way that Moody distinguished his posts from Suzakus when discussing their posting styles day 1 with Wisp seemed non-informed. And based on Sabrar's read list, it also seemed he was dressing up moody for a future miselim.

-Jedi seems like a good possibility to me if it were not for Ducky's claim, hence why the info would be nice. But if he's not going to out it and has ran it by Madge, I guess I will just have to take their word on it. One thing that points to Jedi is Marklin's botched claim. I can't imagine anyone else here would have given the go-ahead on that.

-It doesn't make sense to eliminate Mathblade today because he is our cop and will self-resolve.

-The worst is the absolute best elimination. I've laid out my case for why I think he's scum here. He is not at all cleared because there was another scum alive Night 1 when he was blocked. I think it is between the worst and Jedi, and if Jedi is the worst's inno, that only leaves him.

Vote: the worst

@Madge
@Wam
@WMU
@moody
@jedi

join me

https://youtu.be/OA8wkz0uGLE

At this point I had both outed my result on Jedi, and reviewed your point about WMU and I'm not convinced that is outside the realm of bussing. Please read my posts when you're making demands of me.

Seven wrote: ↑Mon Dec 06, 2021 12:08 am I want to know how Jedi is town. Are you just saying he is town because you know his ability is real?

MathBlade wrote: ↑Mon Dec 06, 2021 1:50 am

the worst wrote: ↑Sun Dec 05, 2021 11:55 pm @mathblade would you mind blocking in this order?
first priority: wmu
second priority: wam
third priority: seven
fourth priority: moody

I have a theory

If people don’t listen to who my top scumspect is I have to block there. I also have no reason to block someone who is a town lock to me. I also anticipate being the nightkill so respectfully no. It’s about shrinking the PoE to where scum can’t hide.

I think that’s Madge or WMU. Madge’s paranoia claims make no sense and seems like it’s shade on me for no good reason.

the worst wrote: ↑Mon Dec 06, 2021 5:18 am

MathBlade wrote: ↑Mon Dec 06, 2021 1:50 am

the worst wrote: ↑Sun Dec 05, 2021 11:55 pm @mathblade would you mind blocking in this order?
first priority: wmu
second priority: wam
third priority: seven
fourth priority: moody

I have a theory

If people don’t listen to who my top scumspect is I have to block there. I also have no reason to block someone who is a town lock to me. I also anticipate being the nightkill so respectfully no. It’s about shrinking the PoE to where scum can’t hide.

I think that’s Madge or WMU. Madge’s paranoia claims make no sense and seems like it’s shade on me for no good reason.

I get it, but the pool of possible scum is so, so small. If we optimise night actions we win 100%

Sorry its annoying but wincon etc.