Tales of Desolation mafia Day 2

[EGW]

I love you. I hope we get to chat and hang out outside the game. Anyone want to pounce on BoomFrog with me?

UNVOTE
VOTE: BoomFrog

Unvote; Vote: Boomfrog

[EGW]

I am not opposed to your vote for me. I know you like to build competing wagons.

I do. Why are you voting me by the way. Talk to me about that.

[heuristically_alone]

VOTE: Boomfrog

[heuristically_alone]

Because I don't trust your agenda and I've been played by scum before the exact same way that you're doing now.

[EGW]

Because I don't trust your agenda and I've been played by scum before the exact same way that you're doing now.

This sounds like your previous scum game I have seen, look here:

but I keep thinking about what Bessie said about being suspicious of players whose reads matched the setup and I am inclined to agree.

[heuristically_alone]

Your logic on me and sabrar and me as scum mates is so absolutely purely illogical and makes zero sense. I literally don't believe you could ever actually believe that was true. I refuse to believe you're that unintelligent.

[EGW]

This was in reference to me stating there were 3 scum in the setup because it was always a common fact in that size of a game.

[EGW]

Your logic on me and sabrar and me as scum mates is so absolutely purely illogical and makes zero sense. I literally don't believe you could ever actually believe that was true. I refuse to believe you're that unintelligent.

I've retracted the association claim. I just thought Sabrar's vote on me was weird while waiting for my case on you. Yet you voted along with it. You didn't vote me before at all. I will say I got ahead of myself with the solve. I did believe it and I 100% believe you are scum here. I don't think you actually believe I have an agenda here.

[EGW]

Since everyone is scum until proven innocent, here is my reads list:

Not scum
NA

Secret Mod
Madge

Scum (least to most)
heuristically_alone
ahippo
Freddino
Makhaira
Bessie
TehBubblez
Sabrar
Laserguy
Wam
Bop
Moody7277
JC_DADDY25
EGW
Boomfrog

[EGW]

This is still very odd to me from the beginning of the game.

[EGW]

heury: I don't think I ever saw them using the point system. -1

Also Heury, since it seems you haven't used the point system before, why are you using it this game for the first time?

Why is this the first time Bessie is hounding on people for misinterpreted her reads list for the first time? Why is it that boomfrog once spoke entirely in woofs for a couple game days? I don't play mafia much anymore so why not try something new? Honestly I'm not putting that much thought into the value of measurement. Mainly just a baseline to distinguish if something pings me or if something seems towny.

[EGW]

Also, my concern is that Hippo never gave reads before replacing out. Regardless of their reason for doing so, during the time between then and them mentioning their day off, no reads.

I also want Mak to give some sort of reads list. Really important I think. We really haven't gotten as much content from him and I think we should have that.

[EGW]

Your logic on me and sabrar and me as scum mates is so absolutely purely illogical and makes zero sense. I literally don't believe you could ever actually believe that was true. I refuse to believe you're that unintelligent.

I'm liable to get distracted and be wrong. I'm going in circles with reads today, and it's frustrating me. I'm trying to make sure I get it right. However, this post comes off as townie and not the forced tone I'm familiar with from your scum game. I think your vote on Boomfrog was timed weird. So I'm going to re-read the thread and let the thread breathe with a better perspective, as we are still waiting for others to claim and even post content.

Unvote

[madge]

What the heck this moved fast.

Sabrar and egw are being very fishy. Sabrar has moved into my neutral box instead of my town box. I would be keen to wagon on egw at this point. He's vacillating so much, it feels like he's not putting care into his reads. I think changing your mind is always a strength, of course, but I swear he changed it 3 times in 12 hours which feels excessive

[EGW]

It comes from me reading old games where I tunneled town the whole game and never changed my mind. I hate that.

[madge]

I also know that it's not my turn to claim yet but I might not be around for 12 hours and I'd rather not slow down the role call so

Not aligned with calamity, yes shepherd. Also a miller.

Phone posting so I will go check what game I'm from

[madge]

I checked my wiki page and I'm listed as in both games

[moody7277]

What the heck this moved fast.

Sabrar and egw are being very fishy. Sabrar has moved into my neutral box instead of my town box. I would be keen to wagon on egw at this point. He's vacillating so much, it feels like he's not putting care into his reads. I think changing your mind is always a strength, of course, but I swear he changed it 3 times in 12 hours which feels excessive

So what's your probability that they're both wolves and Emperor Sabrartine is sacrificing EGW to clear himself?

[madge]

Pretty low, I think bus for no reason is very poor form from scum. I would say tvt or tvs or if we have different scum teams they're from opposing ones. I always tend to think early scuffles are from two town as scum doesn't want to stick out so much

[madge]

Also I don't think there's anything wrong with changing your mind, just flip flopping implies to me that you weren't actually as confident as you seemed to be

There's a difference between "I think x is scum... Oh wait no it's y" and "guys I've solved the game. It's x, 100%......wait no it's 100% y for real this time". Maybe I just skimmed but I got more of the impression that egw (and sabrar I think) were coming across as type 2

[heuristically_alone]

Aligned with Lord of Calamity, not Shepard. Therion

[heuristically_alone]

This is still very odd to me from the beginning of the game.

What about it is odd?

Your posts are giving me backlash. I want to scum read you with this agenda to link some townies together and call them scum. But your whiplash almost indecisiveness makes me want to town read you.

[JC_DADDY25]

Aligned with Lord of Calamity, not Shepard. Therion

What do you mean by Therion?

[JC_DADDY25]

I checked my wiki page and I'm listed as in both games

Why did you check the wiki page?

[JC_DADDY25]

I checked my wiki page and I'm listed as in both games

Why did you check the wiki page?

Nevermind, I checked my info and answered my own question.