Are we human or are we dancer mafia (game over, Dancers win!)

[Theallieza]

Vote: EGW

[Makhaira]

Funnily enough, I was going to offer my vote as a proxy to Alli today, so please take mine.

this is the ultimate move to humiliate me if you're snowing me lmaooooooo this feels so grime

[Theallieza]

Tree stump on you is an odd choice

this feels like shade but know it probably isnt meant that way lmao

Quite the opposite. You said there were two abilities, stump and kill, targeting you, which I assume means the stump was targeting you from Town, which I think is a very odd choice. Like one of those vig kills that I just stare at and figure out the logic that led there.

[Makhaira]

willing to take REASONABLE homework assignments to keep me on task, like you can tell me posts you want to me re-read or read in context etc but dont be a dick about it. Im basically willing to be a soundboard here but Im also not going to always be 100% open with my thought process because I need snow insurance, especially if I get to stump for the rest of the game. but yeah send me shit to look at and feel free to ask questions but just being real with yall I do not have a full solve rn so dont even ask. obviously I still think heury is a great play and place to start rn unless the slot can have a redemption arc

[Theallieza]

Can't figure out

[Makhaira]

Quite the opposite. You said there were two abilities, stump and kill, targeting you, which I assume means the stump was targeting you from Town, which I think is a very odd choice. Like one of those vig kills that I just stare at and figure out the logic that led there.

right but thats the part that feels like lowkey shade

[Makhaira]

EGW I TOLD YOU I WAS TOWN WHY YOU ALWAYS ON SIGHT WITH ME D1 THESE DAYS IT MAKES ME SAD (you better not just be scum otherwise you are good at faking distrust in me)

also come play wow with me again bro TWW is hype

[Seven]

Funnily enough, I was going to offer my vote as a proxy to Alli today, so please take mine.

this is the ultimate move to humiliate me if you're snowing me lmaooooooo this feels so grime

That is not my way. It is logical for a known town entity to have voting power over an unknown who will produce sufficient content through their voice.

[Makhaira]

alright probably done for the night, tbh can't promise more than like one full catch every 24 hours, I will try to post after every catchup, night yall get chatting please so I can read you all and solve =) (yes I will ruthlessly advocate for your yeet if you lurk)

[Seven]

Quite the opposite. You said there were two abilities, stump and kill, targeting you, which I assume means the stump was targeting you from Town, which I think is a very odd choice. Like one of those vig kills that I just stare at and figure out the logic that led there.

right but thats the part that feels like lowkey shade

I think, perhaps, the two of you are seeing the functions of the role differently. I think you are taking at as you would only be stumped if you were also killed? While laser is taking it as you would be stumped regardless of being killed.

[Theallieza]

Quite the opposite. You said there were two abilities, stump and kill, targeting you, which I assume means the stump was targeting you from Town, which I think is a very odd choice. Like one of those vig kills that I just stare at and figure out the logic that led there.

right but thats the part that feels like lowkey shade

Sorry. I just mean that I thought your play was reasonable and townie enough that I would never have considered you for something of that nature, especially considering how many alternatives would have been more useful to hit.

willing to take REASONABLE homework assignments to keep me on task, like you can tell me posts you want to me re-read or read in context etc but dont be a dick about it. Im basically willing to be a soundboard here but Im also not going to always be 100% open with my thought process because I need snow insurance, especially if I get to stump for the rest of the game. but yeah send me shit to look at and feel free to ask questions but just being real with yall I do not have a full solve rn so dont even ask. obviously I still think heury is a great play and place to start rn unless the slot can have a redemption arc

Speaking of which, I have been thinking a lot about this game during the night phase and I think I have a solve that actually makes sense and I feel like explains a lot of why this game has been feeling so off to me. I'll probably take a day or two to assemble my notes and see what else shakes out from the Night, but I will be looking for your feedback when I get there.

[EGW]

Good morning.

Vote: Thealliza

[EGW]

EGW I TOLD YOU I WAS TOWN WHY YOU ALWAYS ON SIGHT WITH ME D1 THESE DAYS IT MAKES ME SAD (you better not just be scum otherwise you are good at faking distrust in me)

also come play wow with me again bro TWW is hype

I realized I was wrong and told you already. You made a good point that you don't try hard at D1 when I do.

[Makhaira]

the shade im implying is taking it as "I don't know why Mak was stumped" intuitively reads to me as "why would a townie at this point want to hedge against a mak NK and preserve town!mak's input"

unless this is multiball or theres a vig, treestump always fails when targeting mafia, so the implication is someone found me townie enough to hedge against scum trying to elim me as treestump atleast in my experience only triggers upon NK. but of course that presentation can reasonably vary if the power has limits imposed like triggering limits or duration limits

anyway not trying to make a mountain out of a molehill here I was just joking around

[EGW]

Also yes I do value your input. I want you active.

[EGW]

I also don't think the mak choice as Tree stump is odd.

[Seven]

atleast in my experience only triggers upon NK.

Right, and this is where you differ.

[madge]

I'm keen to proxy vote Mak, I was going to sheep dead townies like always and y'know you're the dead townie that mafia wanted to kill (unless doc was succesful and we have a vig lol?), so honestly this seems pretty ideal for me?

more madge personal life content

also i mentioned i was playing in a mafia game to my boyf and he wanted to know the theme and i said " are we human or are we daNCER" and he had a look of recognition and i'm like "oh so YOU know the song?" and he's like "yeah, everyone knows the song, i bet you you'd know it if i played it for you"

anyway he played it for me and i didn't recognise it, so lol. i am vindicated

[Theallieza]

the shade im implying is taking it as "I don't know why Mak was stumped" intuitively reads to me as "why would a townie at this point want to hedge against a mak NK and preserve town!mak's input"

unless this is multiball or theres a vig, treestump always fails when targeting mafia, so the implication is someone found me townie enough to hedge against scum trying to elim me as treestump atleast in my experience only triggers upon NK. but of course that presentation can reasonably vary if the power has limits imposed like triggering limits or duration limits

anyway not trying to make a mountain out of a molehill here I was just joking around

Ah, okay, I think we understand the role differently, yes. I have seen stump before as essentially a vig kill but the player sticks around.

[EGW]

Also Mak I'm addicted to FF14 and Yugioh Master Duel so not likely to play WoW.

[Makhaira]

the shade im implying is taking it as "I don't know why Mak was stumped" intuitively reads to me as "why would a townie at this point want to hedge against a mak NK and preserve town!mak's input"

unless this is multiball or theres a vig, treestump always fails when targeting mafia, so the implication is someone found me townie enough to hedge against scum trying to elim me as treestump atleast in my experience only triggers upon NK. but of course that presentation can reasonably vary if the power has limits imposed like triggering limits or duration limits

anyway not trying to make a mountain out of a molehill here I was just joking around

Ah, okay, I think we understand the role differently, yes. I have seen stump before as essentially a vig kill but the player sticks around.

ok then yeah that you and seven are completely right thats where the diff in interpretation comes from

[Makhaira]

Also Mak I'm addicted to FF14 and Yugioh Master Duel so not likely to play WoW.

rip but fair

[EGW]

mad wtf at me getting shot I dont even think I was playing that townie last phase fml, maybe someone caught on to that and reasoned I was trying to a hide a PR

not the strongest PR of all time, psychic was passive and gave me the name and mechanics of any roles that targeted me at night. The only two roles to do so were the killing role and the treestump role so no one else went after me as far as I can tell and I don't know of any other PRs in the game sorry

Clutch af

[EGW]

Vote: EGW

So I'm curious how far you are going to push this and why. Go into it.

[Theallieza]

Vote: EGW

So I'm curious how far you are going to push this and why. Go into it.

If you think that is a joke vote, I assure you it is not.

I will discuss my reads in excruciating detail later in the Day.