Are we human or are we dancer mafia (game over, Dancers win!)

[bessie]

Morning bark.

Bessie: I always confirm in the same way every game. Thoughts on that?

I reviewed the games in this forum and the games on Page 1 of DGames and I could only find one game that you played where there was a confirmation phase (Millerizer Mafia) to verify your claim. In that game, I was doing confirmation post analysis so I feel that this would support putting you in the group in which I put you.

Chuckle-worthy, as in "X is totally scum because they used an exclamation point. " Even though I've seen it used several times, I remain dubious about the confirmation post analysis (most likely because I am not able to use the trick myself), but I'm not going to denigrate anyone who tries the method. I will note that this does make a tie between you and Thea.

Suspicious for reasons.
1. You misread my opening post. I interpreted the explanation point as town lean, not scum lean.
2. This read was painstakingly analyzed in the post you quoted. Still town lean. I only made two posts and you didn’t read either of them carefully.
3. Conclusion that this ties me to Theallieza which I am noting for now.

Well, I wanted to make sure you had something to talk about.

You remembered that I am a reactive player!

[somitomi]

This is Town Seven.

Does the height of the vertical arrows indicate something or is that just for readability?
Also, I miss the colour gradient

I might give him the slightest town lean because he wasn’t worried about conforming.

How would it influence your read if I told you I specifically did something non-conforming just for you, you, you?

I dont think I've ever seen EGW make a post like this, wild

What is wild about it?

is the bolded a joke? tone over internet is hard

Well, I wasn't particularly serious when I typed that, but I'm not sure it'd qualify as a joke. [quote=Theallieza post_id=72987 time=1725107491

I also just realized I wasnt included on theas scumber line and dont feel included sadge =(

Wanna trade places?

Performative? The vibe I get is kind of "Look, I'm active and engaged" without actually saying anything.

Gosh, sorry my throwaway line about people doing their usual stuff wasn't worded accurately enough

I think Seven most likely attacks EGW if and only if Seven is Town and sincerely believes EGW is scum. The edge case is if Seven is scum and believes EGW is 3rd party.

Interesting. Do you think there are third parties in the game?

Without going into detail, the grammatical and stylistic structure of this sentence suggests deviation from the reverse Voight-Kampff test used to verify the emotional suppression of us humans.

Jesse, what the hell are you talking about?

I feel like not enough people are on theme, there was a lot more roleplay in the AI Mafia game. Beside that, there's mostly the normal day-1 posing and trash reads (trash as in meant to be throwaway/revised later in the game).

Does the lack of roleplay factor into your read on people?

[somitomi]

Oops, ignore the mangled half quote tag, sorry.

[Theallieza]

This is Town Seven.

Does the height of the vertical arrows indicate something or is that just for readability?
Also, I miss the colour gradient

I'll try to put the colour in next time. The arrow height is just for readability.

I think Seven most likely attacks EGW if and only if Seven is Town and sincerely believes EGW is scum. The edge case is if Seven is scum and believes EGW is 3rd party.

Interesting. Do you think there are third parties in the game?

My guess is no. Adum is not native to xkcd and we run a lot more 3p than most other sites. But no way to rule it out at this point.

[Theallieza]

I can't find the quote quickly on my phone but @Makheira: everyone who isn't on my line is null.

[AdumbroDeus]

Vote count 2

1. Makhaira - 0:
2. Wam - 1: Makhaira
3. Bessie - 0:
4. heuristically_alone - 0:
5. Gluelock - 1: Moody7277
6. Madge - 1: EGW
7. Seven - 1: somitomi
8. Theallieza - 0:
9. somitomi - 0:
10. Freddino18 - 0:
11. moody7277 - 0:
12. JC_DADDY25 - 0:
13. EGW - 2: Seven, Madge

Yes Extension - 6 : Theallieza, EGW, Makhaira, Bessie, Madge, Wan
No Extension - 0 : Seven

The deadline is set for Friday September 6th at 12 am EST.

[heuristically_alone]

Does the height of the vertical arrows indicate something or is that just for readability?
Also, I miss the colour gradient

[/quote]
+1 Somi

no heury either jeepers

I'll be honest. Got addicted to Slay the Spire this week and totally forgot the game started

Heury, moody, EGW, Makhaira, Wam – Suspicious. They know me well and may have confirmed as they did not to draw my attention. Note: I’m pretty sure Wam has said before that he’s posted a neutral confirmation post not to draw my attention, but I can’t remember the game. It was on xkcd.

Can confirm I'm scared to not give a neutral confirmation post in games with Bessie

This song is very famous. I presumed Madge’s comment to be a joke

Why not let Madge answer and explain that herself?

+1

This song is very famous. I presumed Madge’s comment to be a joke.
[/quote]
Seems to know for sure the game is referencing the song. -1

I don’t do soul reads, which would require having a soul, but I feel that Theallieza would not post this if they were non-town.

Bessie claiming right out the gate? What a miracle

so like, i have to know - is the title a reference to a song or something?

Asking the important questions. +1

[heuristically_alone]

Wow that was really poor editing

[EGW]

I reviewed the games in this forum and the games on Page 1 of DGames and I could only find one game that you played where there was a confirmation phase (Millerizer Mafia) to verify your claim. In that game, I was doing confirmation post analysis so I feel that this would support putting you in the group in which I put you.

Baldur's Gate Mafia:

Confirm

Halloween Mafia:

Confirm.

Millerizer Mafia

Confirm.

[EGW]

Vote: Seven

Why are you voting Seven?

[madge]

Does it change your read that she is saying it wasn't a joke? I don't think either of these things are alignment indicative for Madge.

No. She did this as third party scum before, Bessie pointed out that she was joking when I had a problem with her lack of follow up. Example below:

Madge, why are you not responding to Bessies answer to your question?

Interesting. This is useful to know.

oh my god read the context! Bessie told me on PAGE ONE that she didn't like my content. what psycopath thinks that this means ANYTHING? also like what, u think that because i thought something serious(????? was bessie possibly serious about my content on PAGE ONE not b eing good enough? knowing bessie PROBABLY because she has 5D chess but SERIOUSLY??? PAGE ONE???????? i dare you to find a g ame in HISTORY where i had good content on PAGE FREAKING ONE)

this is why i don't play mafia much, people misinterpret me because i am too much of a manic pixie dream girl for 'em

bessie - i know u love confirmation post analysis and u missed ONE important thing: not only do i get to talk about myself to an audience but i get to SAVE THE DAY by replacing in and start the game after 2 days of post-confirmation waiting. so i was excited to come in and save the day. which apparently m akes me scum, so whatever. i always get read scum. i'll try and do better this time, but it's off to a great start since i *c hecked notes* asked a genuine, non-joke question and *checks notes* was excited to play this game thing we are all playing for fun???????

yeah i don't take things personally, i take EVERYTHING personally, everything is about me, i think i could legit be diagnosed with narcissistic personality disorder except even though i have narcissistic feelings about myself i don't do any of the personality disorder stuff around being mean, which is prob for the best because being mean sucks and also getting d iagnosed with NPD, whooo boy, the stigma amirite?

do mafia have daychat? it's probably in the rules which i did read ut didn't memorise.

@MAK: no i mean cool calm and collective. it's a reference to Survivor 30: Blue Collar vs White Collar vs No Collar, Rodney LaVoie Jr used the phrase to describe himself. and it's vibes. i am telling you it's all vibes, Seven normally has a very imposing manner about them and this time it's slightly less imposing.

@heury: oh my god i got super addicted to slay the spire and then i found out you can install mods in steam so i got addicted to downfall and all the mods t hat add new cards and events, such a good game!!!!


ACTUAL GAME THOUGHTS THAT MATTER (everything else can prob be skipped):

i am confused about how anyone can get readings from somi and moody, i have forgotten about them already. Seven and bessie are both larger than life, but that doesn't mean they're town, just that they have impressions on things? a trap i find i fall into is town-reading high volume/highly logical players

as much as EGW sucks for voting for me, i don't actually want to keep my joke vote on much longer as i can see myself doing confirmation bias of why i think EGW is scummy scum, so i'll unvote to improve neutrality:

unvote EGW

for a setup, with 13 players i'd imagine we have a third party. given it's a mountainous game (is that the right term?), i'd expect 2-3 scum, but i am no expert scum balancer.

subjective vibes-based groupings of all players:

posting is noticeable, but this doesn't mean they're town: bessie, seven

don't even remember them posting: wam, gluelock, moody7277

middle of the road: makhaira, somitomi, EGW

seems to be phoning it in: heuri, madge, Theallieza, Freddino18, JC_DADDY25

I was going to rank people within the groupings but I think mak is the towniest middle person and Thea is the towniest phoning it in person (apart from me obviously, but i wanted to be honest about which group i belong in).

in general i on't want to vote off the "noticeable posters" group, because they'll have enough rope. i think the don't remember posting group is the most fertile ground for looking for voteoff candidates, because if i can't remember that they're posting then i'm not going to remember their scummy or twonie actions, and in a vacuum we want to get rid of people who are hard to vote off later. i say that as someone who is often kept until the end by scum because i am so bad at this game, it's an absolute pain if halfway through we're left with the "phoning it in" players because we have so little to go on. i remember in one game we were voting between 2 candidates and one had just kinda fallen off the map for several half Days so we had very, very little to go on.

i personally believe the D1 vote is a crapshoot so best to shoot those craps amongst the people we will be frustrated about not having enough information on later

[EGW]

seems to be phoning it in: madge, Theallieza

In what way does Theallieza seem to be phoning it in to you, and why do you put yourself in that group?

[madge]

i told you it's vibes. next question?

[EGW]

I don't have anymore questions. Looking at Millerizer mafia and comparing it to here, your response to my vote pressure seems to be that of townie frustration. I do not have any other scumreads at the moment.

Unvote

[Seven]

then i found out you can install mods in steam so i got addicted to downfall and all the mods t hat add new cards and events, such a good game!!!!

I didn't know this. There goes the rest of my day.

[heuristically_alone]

i am too much of a manic pixie dream girl for 'em

This is an incredibly accurate description of Madge

[bessie]

Bedtime bark!

I might give him the slightest town lean because he wasn’t worried about conforming.

How would it influence your read if I told you I specifically did something non-conforming just for you, you, you?

I would think you were lying. Your confirmation post was not nonconforming in a way that was designed to get my attention. It would not influence my read for this reason.

Without going into detail, the grammatical and stylistic structure of this sentence suggests deviation from the reverse Voight-Kampff test used to verify the emotional suppression of us humans.

Jesse, what the hell are you talking about?

-1

Can confirm I'm scared to not give a neutral confirmation post in games with Bessie

awesome.jpg (61.66 KiB) Viewed 273 times

I don’t do soul reads, which would require having a soul, but I feel that Theallieza would not post this if they were non-town.

Bessie claiming right out the gate? What a miracle

It’s not a claim it’s my real-life persona making an appearance. I never claim without reason. On the internet I am an extroverted happy loving and lovable labrador with emotions and feelings. In real life I am Rayna Kapec.


Goshfrickindarnit EGW I thought I checked all the games on this forum. Ok I was wrong. It still doesn’t affect my confirmation post read because in all those game you already know me but I will keep this in mind for future games.

oh my god read the context! Bessie told me on PAGE ONE that she didn't like my content.

I think this has happened more than once.

This is such a Madge post I don’t even. Noting this for now.

[somitomi]

Does the height of the vertical arrows indicate something or is that just for readability?
Also, I miss the colour gradient

+1 Somi

But why?

This song is very famous. I presumed Madge’s comment to be a joke.

Seems to know for sure the game is referencing the song. -1

Even more why?

Bessie claiming right out the gate? What a miracle

I might be missing something but I don't see the claim

Vote: Seven

Why are you voting Seven?

Because it was amusing at the time

Unvote

in general i on't want to vote off the "noticeable posters" group, because they'll have enough rope. i think the don't remember posting group is the most fertile ground for looking for voteoff candidates, because if i can't remember that they're posting then i'm not going to remember their scummy or twonie actions, and in a vacuum we want to get rid of people who are hard to vote off later. i say that as someone who is often kept until the end by scum because i am so bad at this game, it's an absolute pain if halfway through we're left with the "phoning it in" players because we have so little to go on.

Please don't. A lurker flip this early gives us absolutely no information because when we go look at who they talked to what they said it's just "oh, nobody and nothing" and then D2 ends up being D1 the second part. Especially if they flip town, which in my experience is likelier to happen than not. I'd much rather elim someone who's actually done something and then deal with lurkers later, when there are at least some votes from them to scrutinise, so we're not just shooting people randomly for being too quiet.

I would think you were lying. Your confirmation post was not nonconforming in a way that was designed to get my attention. It would not influence my read for this reason.

Well I wouldn't want to be too obvious about it...

[madge]

I don't agree with you somi but I respect that you actually have an opinion

that said, if the lurkers are forced to vote due to the "no voteoff if no majority" rule, this might improve things. i just remember horror situations where we had to vote between two lurkers none of whom had ever voted and it's like...... yay

[Freddino18]

do mafia have daychat? it's probably in the rules which i did read ut didn't memorise.

The rules are a general ruleset with allowances for daychat but we don't even have a confirmation that there are actual scum.The rules are the vaguest on actual mechanics that I have ever seen. It's either that this game is entirely vanilla, or Adum is hiding a big stinker (wth is the name for one of those games?) (also I always phone it in until I do my in-depth analysis)

September 4rd

Fake-Vote Adum

[EGW]

Fred, you missed a question from Somi.

[Freddino18]

Thanks, thought I answered already.

The roleplay adds a fun element and makes it feel less like vanilla, which is what the lack of specific rules seems to imply. If this is going to be fun, we gotta make it fun. No impact on reads because I'm illiterate.

[EGW]

Mod: Please prod Wam and Gluelock.

[Gluelock]

No. She did this as third party scum before, Bessie pointed out that she was joking when I had a problem with her lack of follow up. Example below:

Interesting. This is useful to know.

oh my god read the context! Bessie told me on PAGE ONE that she didn't like my content. what psycopath thinks that this means ANYTHING? also like what, u think that because i thought something serious(????? was bessie possibly serious about my content on PAGE ONE not b eing good enough? knowing bessie PROBABLY because she has 5D chess but SERIOUSLY??? PAGE ONE???????? i dare you to find a g ame in HISTORY where i had good content on PAGE FREAKING ONE)

this is why i don't play mafia much, people misinterpret me because i am too much of a manic pixie dream girl for 'em

bessie - i know u love confirmation post analysis and u missed ONE important thing: not only do i get to talk about myself to an audience but i get to SAVE THE DAY by replacing in and start the game after 2 days of post-confirmation waiting. so i was excited to come in and save the day. which apparently m akes me scum, so whatever. i always get read scum. i'll try and do better this time, but it's off to a great start since i *c hecked notes* asked a genuine, non-joke question and *checks notes* was excited to play this game thing we are all playing for fun???????

yeah i don't take things personally, i take EVERYTHING personally, everything is about me, i think i could legit be diagnosed with narcissistic personality disorder except even though i have narcissistic feelings about myself i don't do any of the personality disorder stuff around being mean, which is prob for the best because being mean sucks and also getting d iagnosed with NPD, whooo boy, the stigma amirite?

do mafia have daychat? it's probably in the rules which i did read ut didn't memorise.

@MAK: no i mean cool calm and collective. it's a reference to Survivor 30: Blue Collar vs White Collar vs No Collar, Rodney LaVoie Jr used the phrase to describe himself. and it's vibes. i am telling you it's all vibes, Seven normally has a very imposing manner about them and this time it's slightly less imposing.

@heury: oh my god i got super addicted to slay the spire and then i found out you can install mods in steam so i got addicted to downfall and all the mods t hat add new cards and events, such a good game!!!!


ACTUAL GAME THOUGHTS THAT MATTER (everything else can prob be skipped):

i am confused about how anyone can get readings from somi and moody, i have forgotten about them already. Seven and bessie are both larger than life, but that doesn't mean they're town, just that they have impressions on things? a trap i find i fall into is town-reading high volume/highly logical players

as much as EGW sucks for voting for me, i don't actually want to keep my joke vote on much longer as i can see myself doing confirmation bias of why i think EGW is scummy scum, so i'll unvote to improve neutrality:

unvote EGW

for a setup, with 13 players i'd imagine we have a third party. given it's a mountainous game (is that the right term?), i'd expect 2-3 scum, but i am no expert scum balancer.

subjective vibes-based groupings of all players:

posting is noticeable, but this doesn't mean they're town: bessie, seven

don't even remember them posting: wam, gluelock, moody7277

middle of the road: makhaira, somitomi, EGW

seems to be phoning it in: heuri, madge, Theallieza, Freddino18, JC_DADDY25

I was going to rank people within the groupings but I think mak is the towniest middle person and Thea is the towniest phoning it in person (apart from me obviously, but i wanted to be honest about which group i belong in).

in general i on't want to vote off the "noticeable posters" group, because they'll have enough rope. i think the don't remember posting group is the most fertile ground for looking for voteoff candidates, because if i can't remember that they're posting then i'm not going to remember their scummy or twonie actions, and in a vacuum we want to get rid of people who are hard to vote off later. i say that as someone who is often kept until the end by scum because i am so bad at this game, it's an absolute pain if halfway through we're left with the "phoning it in" players because we have so little to go on. i remember in one game we were voting between 2 candidates and one had just kinda fallen off the map for several half Days so we had very, very little to go on.

i personally believe the D1 vote is a crapshoot so best to shoot those craps amongst the people we will be frustrated about not having enough information on later

Vote: Madge

[Gluelock]

Mod: Please prod Wam and Gluelock.

Oh hi