Pick Your Poison Mafia (Day 2)

[EGW]

Votecount 2.7

1. Boomfrog
2. Swiss
3. Madge
4. Seven
5. JC
6. Fonti
7. bessie
8. Sabrar

Not voting:
Boomfrog, Swiss, Madge, Seven, JC, Fonti, Bessie, Sabrar

Important Links:
Game links and Vote Counts

Notes:
N/A

With 8 players, it takes 5 votes to eliminate.

The deadline for Day 2 is Friday December 15th at 11:59PM EST

[bessie]

bessie you're full of shit and I should have yeeted you yesterday

Please explain exactly why I am full of shit. After you answer my other questions.

I'll pass.

Ok. You don't have to explain why I am full of shit. Perhaps I can glean why you feel this way after you answer the questions in this post.

[boomfrog]

Jeepus....

I don't have the bandwidth to talk you two down again. Your both town. Work together or yeet me and end the game.

[boomfrog]

You called me certain scum right out the gate, and now you're acting like I overreacted.

Fonti is almost certainly scum.

But whatever. You've already committed. If we are both town we've already lost.

[Seven]

moody's highest town read was bessie (+4). Probably who he targeted.

[bessie]

moody's highest town read was bessie (+4). Probably who he targeted.

Perhaps. Did I also kill Fred? Please explain the remark quoted below.

Whichever one of you killed Fred (side eye at bessie) needs to sit in timeout.

Explain this. In as much detail as you feel appropriate.

[Sabrar]

but like, moody/LG, d1, etc. Sabrar is the obvious doc target, right? There's a joke here that Sabrar is always killed N1. to me it seems like he's the most likely doc target from members of the xkcdcore.

I am indeed the super obvious doc-target after Seven specifically brings up the above mentioned historical evidence. That's why scum is less likely to target me in the first place, so now weak doc is free to protect/test someone else. It's all mindgames

[madge]

yeah but then my confirmation bias made all of your behaviour fit with the narrative i'd invented. flawless logic.

[Swiss]

I thought he appeared townie yesterDay by forcing an elim and not caring on who.

This is weak reasoning. Scum also doesn't care if all wagons are town.

Yes...but no.

Went about it in a positive way and gets +vibe for that

[Swiss]

Fucking hell.

This I like

[Swiss]

Logic is not variable.

This inane AI like comment I dislike

[Swiss]

are you ready to reveal my SUSPECTED DOC TARGET?

firstly I am SHOCKED, shocked nobody else brought it up until maybe fonti but fonti was missing a CRUCIAL ELEMENT

You really, really remind me of Kataefi.

I like that you go after a player in towncore.
I dislike that the reasoning is empty.

[Swiss]

Boom buddying up to Zen is not what I expected to see. Boom is making a play i just need to understand what the play

My instinct is
Swiss/Bessie/JC/Sabrar Town
Madge Font Likely town
Zen Boon Scum

I appreciate this necessitates I am incorrect

Theres 3 scum my guy.

See bolded. Dislike the skimming in D2.

[Swiss]

I should have read up before posting my above post. Yeah this sounds legit. @seven I'm going to rely on your meta read of jc. But he feels really town.

And Fonti is right that my scum team pick wouldn't be targeted by moody/LG.

This I do like

[Swiss]

@Fonti I only said you are probably scum you went to 100. If you are town don't throw this, as scum I'm more manipulative less power wolf.

Why did you promise mak you'd Elim JC? How is that a promise town can make in good faith?

This is dislike. Opportunistic but a good point also.

[Swiss]

bessie you're full of shit and I should have yeeted you yesterday

Please explain exactly why I am full of shit. After you answer my other questions.

I'll pass.

Another barb.

How do you go from 'AI' type to this petty barb.

I don't see a consistent mindset

[Swiss]

But whatever. You've already committed. If we are both town we've already lost.

Hate this

[Swiss]

You and Madge trying to make it seem like you can get anything out of Laser’s death is silly.

Trying to determine what laser did is silly and a waste of time.

moody's highest town read was bessie (+4). Probably who he [LASER] targeted.

I can't reconcile this

[Swiss]

@bessie @Madge @JC, could you respond to this if you haven't yet?

Cop and Doctor.

Why have you answered in this way? Do you not like my question?

This pings me

[Swiss]

I'm not eliminating Wam when he's not here. Yeet bessie. Good info.

What info would you have got?

[EGW]

Nevermind that, I messed up a bump.

[Swiss]

My D1 town reads were good.

Dislike

Town
Freddino - town slipped repeatedly
Makhaira - I think the cumulative slips add up to sincere.
Sabrar- good analysis, giving away a lot of town clears.
bessie - town slip is likely real. Only scum with fonti or seven.
Seven - giving out the Mak town clear was very townie unless exactly buddies with Mak, but was very risky is buddies with mak. Still loses town cred if mak is scum.

moody - fairly null but void analysis so far. Slight town lean
Swiss - Hard to read due to his inability to read. But most of his takes seem to be ligit. Still, like reading a horoscope.
JC-DADDY - ehh shortly after moves to town
madge - slightly scummy but mostly null

fontisian - generally townie but that is well within their scum wheelhouse. Has over emphasized other townies points which is their scum style when trying to manipulate town. (Fonti's pronouns are They/them btw, many seem to have missed that.). If scum then likely buddies with wam.

Wam - Too confident in town reading me and Seven with no reasons.
Scum

I'm going to reread wam to make sure there wasn't a town slip D0.

You townread everyone apart from Wam.

My life would be much easier if you didn't die so early in hAIloween

[fontisian]

You called me certain scum right out the gate, and now you're acting like I overreacted.

Fonti is almost certainly scum.

But whatever. You've already committed. If we are both town we've already lost.

Huh.

Maybe I overreacted.

You still feel like a slimy slime who slimes. I don't think I'm getting over that.

[fontisian]

I'm still trippin over the fact that someone is zensane enough to give double doc. Only Boom and Fonti could be. This also excludes Sabrar from being on the scum team as he would never permit it on his team.

bessie you're full of shit and I should have yeeted you yesterday

Could you use more words to explain how you're getting where you're getting? Like, pick one thought process a d break it down for me.

[fontisian]

My D1 town reads were good.

Dislike

Town
Freddino - town slipped repeatedly
Makhaira - I think the cumulative slips add up to sincere.
Sabrar- good analysis, giving away a lot of town clears.
bessie - town slip is likely real. Only scum with fonti or seven.
Seven - giving out the Mak town clear was very townie unless exactly buddies with Mak, but was very risky is buddies with mak. Still loses town cred if mak is scum.

moody - fairly null but void analysis so far. Slight town lean
Swiss - Hard to read due to his inability to read. But most of his takes seem to be ligit. Still, like reading a horoscope.
JC-DADDY - ehh shortly after moves to town
madge - slightly scummy but mostly null

fontisian - generally townie but that is well within their scum wheelhouse. Has over emphasized other townies points which is their scum style when trying to manipulate town. (Fonti's pronouns are They/them btw, many seem to have missed that.). If scum then likely buddies with wam.

Wam - Too confident in town reading me and Seven with no reasons.
Scum

I'm going to reread wam to make sure there wasn't a town slip D0.

You townread everyone apart from Wam.

My life would be much easier if you didn't die so early in hAIloween
[/quote
These town reads are only good if the scum team is exactly me, madge and JC.