New XKCD Forums

You cant be a liability in yeet or lose as long as you are always trying to solve and push for our win if town.

You are a liability if you selfvote and makes us waste a valuable yeet on yourself just as an attempt for your read to be more valued

@Santy: I want to eliminate non-Wam scum today because I want to use his loud abilities tonight. Additionally, if Adum is indeed 3P, then it may be that he is trying to off the JOATs. What use do they have? Like, Mak does have them loud for today to confirm what they do but thats about it? You thin...

Maybe JC dies because they acted on someone?? Even from an indy pov its hard to imagine why they targeted JC in specific. My safety measure has been "ignore it, assume something weird happens with the mafia factional and see the answer post-game"

My last very weird theory is that there is a world where Adum and Wam are paired as scum, with Adum having a sort of passive observer of every role that acted on them, providing the fakeclaim to Wam. But like, I still strongly townread Adum and Im only doing this trying to make sense of why Adum is ...

@Santy: I want to eliminate non-Wam scum today because I want to use his loud abilities tonight. Additionally, if Adum is indeed 3P, then it may be that he is trying to off the JOATs. What use do they have? Like, Mak does have them loud for today to confirm what they do but thats about it? You thin...

Its infuriating seeing someone try to play this way. Its like the total opposite of trying to work together with the rest

Adum, the reason why Thea and I are trying to figure out the different ways you can be scum isn’t that we are in lala theorycrafting land, it’s that you’re really just quite suspicious, and it doesn’t line up with the “town” result. I’ll case in full all the things I find suspicious later. It's not...

Ty , I appreciate it

I will be very angry if a hammer happens , there's still things I want to do

Makhaira wrote: ↑Wed Nov 20, 2024 4:21 pm Vote: Moody

E-1, please don't hammer until bessie answers my above two questions

If you dont want hammer to happen then maybe unvote and vote back later when they reply

Adum is a bulletproof* godfather. He and moody are on one team. Wam and somi are on the other. He’s possibly lying about the bulletproof and there simply wasn’t a kill N1. This explains why Wam was simultaneously watching the “kill” target. It’s possible Santy is in this somewhere since he has pret...

Apologies, I have been sorta skimming so not really up to date or focused on what has been talked much (will have to reread later. Strongarm modifier goes through both roleblocks and protection usually? I have been thinking that if moody scum and carried the kill with strongarm (ignoring Seven roleb...

Santy Thea - Fred Adum Mak Seven Bessie Moody Wam Current readlist kinda sorted Edited to better reflect grade of confidence between some reads Why Mak over seven? I think Mak is more unpaired + less indy equity. But its not that big of a difference. First answer that came to mind is 'eh maybe I sh...

And also the no cop on n1, to cop the mason on n2 which didnt align with their approach from before, just because it was better "objectively" also hard to believe for myself Wam said a couple times that he was paranoid about me/Fred so I don't think this was an entirely unreasonable play....

Also, Im at work and not fully here. And saw Seven saying that JC used the watcher on Adum or something like that. Wouldnt that make it possible that scum wam actually watched or "stole" JC result? Is another mech explanation on why they have that info despite scum attempting to kill adum ...

Bessie progression on somi Also please read since insights of people with more knowledge of bessie's meta are needed Woof bessie – Dog. Wam – Town. somitomi – Town lean. Santygrass – Town lean. Theallieza – Town lean. AdumbroDeus – town lean, however, I am a bit suspicious JC_DADDY25 – neutral the ...

Santygrass wrote: ↑Tue Nov 19, 2024 1:26 pm Santy
Thea - Fred

Adum

Mak
Seven
Bessie

Moody

Wam

Current readlist kinda sorted

Edited to better reflect grade of confidence between some reads

Vote: Makhaira Because of my previous read which, due to circumstances beyond my control, I wasn't able to falsify, and because of the newly relearned lesson that bessie don't bus, and my opinion that she is town in this game. And what about the information of somi claiming to have copped Mak ? Tha...

Santy
Thea - Fred
Adum
Mak
Seven
Bessie
Moody
Wam

Current readlist kinda sorted

And I feel like the people sussing bessie havent really taken my post of bessie progression on somi into account, while people townreading them yes (moody and thea, aknowledging that is a good look meta-wise)

Honestly if somi copped bessie, calling both paranoid as a soft to bessie is kinda dumb, specially because they were also calling before Adum confirmed non-town. And if it was a crumb in purpose, to later not use it just makes it weird. That read of the soft is seeing ghosts and highly influenced by...

Vote: Makhaira Because of my previous read which, due to circumstances beyond my control, I wasn't able to falsify, and because of the newly relearned lesson that bessie don't bus, and my opinion that she is town in this game. And what about the information of somi claiming to have copped Mak ? Tha...

Assuming Adum was the NK target, then it is extremely unlikely that any other scum would bother using their powers on him. Wam evidently did use a power on Adum N1 since he knew the name of bessie's role, and it is obscure enough that the only way he likely could have got it correct is if either 1)...

You still haven't answered my question Santy, why did you protect me? My theory was (and still somewhat is) that you were JoaT and that you used something lik hider/self doc or whatever to avoid death. Then for mafia kills I think after yesterday the targets would be between Seven/Thea/You . Thea i...

And also the no cop on n1, to cop the mason on n2 which didnt align with their approach from before, just because it was better "objectively" also hard to believe for myself