New XKCD Forums

Good luck town, you got this!

somitomi wrote: ↑Thu Feb 13, 2025 10:32 pm Okay, I don't think there's much point in delaying any further, I have mostly smothered the vague paranoia I was feeling and there's not much I could add to the strategy

Vote: Santy

See you guys tomorrow

Somi TMIing game is still going to follow cause Im not the last scum :curtain:

Yes, hard defending ahippo is possible of powerwolfing.

But if they were powerwolfing , there is no reason to start doubting it or slightly shading it instead of maintaining it as strong tbh.

And to me its very whiteknight-coded with just the security/TMI there

Yeah alright, I admit I skimmed this post aside from my own spoiler. I've read it carefully now. I am cautious about relying on reading Bop since the dude snowed all of us pretty hard, but I agree the EGW frustration is real. I'll note that mafia seem to only have night chat so it's possible a scum...

Has phillip played any forum mafia game before btw?

@Boomfrog Yeet preference would be something like Boomfrog >>>> Phillip > EGW >>>>> JC >>> Somi >>> Sabrar/heury . So for your specific question, rn I'd lean more on yeeting phillip, but I also think relies in evidence we get down the line (see: if more mark of suppresion show up is a good look for ...

Above from my legacy post, I had the quotes from Bop ISO related to EGW .

I do think Bop showed genuine frustration to EGW reads, and how Bop refuted every push he was doing to hippo, didnt read to me as partnery to me IMO

My issue is Frog *why* the "townie scumhunting negated by multiball* ONLY applied to Madge . I dont think your reads shifted much on other slots considering multiball option. You decided apparently to only negate madge positives because of multiball and not other peoples? Idk what to say man. ...

Kill me I want to read Gojoe and see if Im right on Frog or not ;-;

Anyways Im eepy and today was very rough at work. See you later zzzz~

Are you convinced that I am scum? Do you think Santy is incapable of this energy level as scum? I'm not. You are just a low town read. My only scum read is Phillip. I was way off on my scum reads this game so I dialed it back. However I found Santy's energy level townie while being the default elim...

My issue is Frog *why* the "townie scumhunting negated by multiball* ONLY applied to Madge . I dont think your reads shifted much on other slots considering multiball option. You decided apparently to only negate madge positives because of multiball and not other peoples?

Santy is townier than Phillip, and would be more beneficial to the game due his desire to solve. You could substitute any name there instead of Santy and it would be true. Doesn't mean that we automatically need to get rid of phillip, just look at how the Fred-yeet came about. That's why you take m...

Another thing to maybe look into is who changed their read on Madge in the second half of D2? She didn't claim to be marked, which I think a townie would almost always do, so suppression mafia could have had a reasonable suspicion on her. Town Lean . 14. Madge - I'm slightly convinced by LG's point...

Unvote EGW
Vote Boomfrog

Legacy purposes hmmyes

There is nl stated explanation to *why* Madged dropped off so hard from Strong town in SoD2 to the suspicion in EoD2 from Boomfrog. The only stated reason said there is not trusting the Miller claim, which was something that madge said D1 and they were fine townreading madge regardless~

Another thing to maybe look into is who changed their read on Madge in the second half of D2? She didn't claim to be marked, which I think a townie would almost always do, so suppression mafia could have had a reasonable suspicion on her. Town Lean . 14. Madge - I'm slightly convinced by LG's point...

I do think that with the proposed plan if somi/EGW are scum there are good odds of it being discovered tomorrow, so maybe its just all a big skill issue on my part . But if they are not then yes I inform you that you will have to re-engage and solve :hmmmyes:

Possible scum Madge - I don't trust the miller claim. @Bop please take note here as well. She claimed late enough that she was confident there were no other millers who might claim, and she likes mechanics, that includes going for an early mechanical clear on herself. Only scum if it's multiball be...

Also, phillip Roleblock last night can only be possible if phillip is lying OR someone else is lying about their actions. If Sabrar can confirm about how their role works against other manipulatives , we can potentially clear JC off of not being able to roleblock phillip even if they were a redirect...

@Santygrass: Why does scum wam point out that Scum sabrar is telling on himself if they are partners? I have them hard unaligned because of that. And Sabrar sincerely thought wam was soft claiming flavor cop which he used for the "mech solve" on EGW. I'm sure they aren't scumbuddies. Sabr...

Possible scum Madge - I don't trust the miller claim. @Bop please take note here as well. She claimed late enough that she was confident there were no other millers who might claim, and she likes mechanics, that includes going for an early mechanical clear on herself. Only scum if it's multiball be...

Madge - Stand by her miller claim, and I tend to agree with her struggling to place people as explicit scum, especially at the game's pace. I like a lot of her takes. This is Bop last read on Madge for the record. They believed the claim and were okay with her, not much sus to be seen. But then aga...

Oh, I see what you mean. Yeah 100% .

They would think that either Madge was sus or that their mark maybe got redirected or something happened to it

Sabrar wrote: ↑Wed Feb 12, 2025 12:17 pm But that was after she was devoured N2, no? I don't think it was ever publicly discussed D2.

Yeah. But I imagine Madge told him during D2 through their chat only no?