New XKCD Forums

Mason chat https://discord.gg/w6bCfuTpTG .... Of all the reasons I considered, of all the arguments you might have made to convince Fredd to vote Santy, "it would be funny" was not on my radar. :mrgreen: I don't really feel like it was hard to convince him, but it was a reason I thought h...

Mason chat
https://discord.gg/w6bCfuTpTG

Good game all! Very well played all around!

Halloween

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

This is driving me nuts. Massive egos getting in the way.

This is literally the best possible endgame for Town. How are we on the verge of losing this?

Hallowe'en

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

We got to 3 player LYLO with two confirmed townies. Hard to ask for a more favorable endgame. Doesn't mean Town can't screw it up on paranoia, but I think Mak will get it right.

My simplistic read going into is that you and Fred are town lovers. So that would effectively be 3/1 mylo and the play is no elim surely? The question was, what was the point in entertaining all of that speculation about independent roles, etc.? From the point of view of Town!you, none of that coul...

I think I'm fine with a no elim or yeeting Wam at this point. I'll be around another hour or so and then close to deadline and will drop a vote one way or the other depending on what Mak wants to do.

AdumbroDeus wrote: ↑Wed Dec 04, 2024 10:19 pm And yes, I know the point of claiming siblings is suggesting you're town, but that's BS.

Not going to lie, I am planning on taking immense satisfaction from proving you wrong.

The lifelink takes away the entire reasoning claiming to save Fredd is townie and it makes no sense to hide it this long because that means town has a nasty surprise in terms of available yeets whenever you're killed, as green check marks with no protection. Strong arming your partner into ending t...

And yes, I know the point of claiming siblings is suggesting you're town, but that's BS. The lifelink takes away the entire reasoning claiming to save Fredd is townie and it makes no sense to hide it this long because that means town has a nasty surprise in terms of available yeets whenever you're ...

AdumbroDeus wrote: ↑Wed Dec 04, 2024 9:54 pm

Theallieza wrote: ↑Wed Dec 04, 2024 9:39 pm

Makhaira wrote: ↑Wed Dec 04, 2024 8:36 pm



Quoting for pings. If you two are life linked (if one of you dies you both die) you need to claim this now. If you are town and dont claim this you are throwing

Yes we are.

Finally. So what's your wincon?

Standard Town wincon.

To be clear: We are Siblings (functionally the same as Lovers).

Makhaira wrote: ↑Wed Dec 04, 2024 8:36 pm

Theallieza wrote: ↑Wed Dec 04, 2024 6:15 pm

Freddino18 wrote: ↑Wed Dec 04, 2024 1:50 pm

Quoting for pings. If you two are life linked (if one of you dies you both die) you need to claim this now. If you are town and dont claim this you are throwing

Yes we are.

So been trying to think through scenarios i think i have covered them all. For the avoidance of doubt I went into today and through most of the day thinking no elim was the right answer. Formatting of the below is awful, on phone so apologies Okay. Why are you entertaining all of this? You have a t...

So been trying to think through scenarios i think i have covered them all. For the avoidance of doubt I went into today and through most of the day thinking no elim was the right answer. Formatting of the below is awful, on phone so apologies 1) Assume adum is correct, thea and Fred are indy and po...

EBWOP fixed quotes thea and fred, do you think we are in 9v3? It's looking that way. I can't rule it out but I think it's more practical to find mafia and if the game doesn't end then we can look for Indies. what are the best reasons not to flip one of your slots to confirm you arent indies and then...

thea and fred, do you think we are in 9v3? It's looking that way. I can't rule it out but I think it's more practical to find mafia and if the game doesn't end then we can look for Indies. what are the best reasons not to flip one of your slots to confirm you arent indies and then win in 2v1 endgam...

That's an amusing misinterpretion. No, this is me trying to persuade mafia not to support you. As mafia I'd have no reason to try to nix the Santy yeet, I've have no reason to suggest somi as an alternative yeet D2, no reason to hammer my partner D3 when Seven was suggesting Wam as an alternative, ...

That doesn't address my question at all. If I'm survivor indy, I would full claim and then Fred and I just vote anyone. If mafia doesn't quickhammer, then we found scum and we win with Town. If mafia does quickhammer then we win with mafia (or they kill us for spite which is out of my control). The...

https://ramenchef.net/nxf/viewtopic.php?p=81728#p81728 Link so we don't have long quote posts. So maybe a terminology thing but SK is not an indy. Indys can win with any faction, SK needs to be last person standing to win. Therefore I don't see how you can apply thay logic that if there was a pair ...

Given you're still maintaining otherwise, Mafia has just as much reason to assume you win alone as town does. And what possible benefit would there for me to do that? There's that obtuseness again. As Seven said, xkcd has a history of working with town compatible indies. If you're say, a survivor l...

Given you're still maintaining otherwise, Mafia has just as much reason to assume you win alone as town does. And what possible benefit would there for me to do that? I really am actually kind of hoping you are scum to be honest. Because if you're Town your play this game has been completely incomp...

7-3-2 is kind of insane like Im extremely skeptical sabrar would sign off on something like this. 9-3 seems more straightforward, 8-2-2 maybe? But its been one kill all game like I think that means we should be updating to 9-3 unless its weird jungle republic stuff and JR is 13 players so I guess i...

7-3-2 is kind of insane like Im extremely skeptical sabrar would sign off on something like this. 9-3 seems more straightforward, 8-2-2 maybe? But its been one kill all game like I think that means we should be updating to 9-3 unless its weird jungle republic stuff and JR is 13 players so I guess i...