New XKCD Forums

Sabrar wrote: ↑Wed Nov 20, 2024 4:13 pm Votals:
moody - 4 - Seven., Thea., Fred., wam.
Makhaira - 2 - moody., bessie.
bessie - 1 - Makhaira.
Adum - 1 - Adum.
wam - 1 - Santygrass.

Not voting: nobody

9 players alive and 6 to hammer

I think the mods are mocking you @Seven.

I am not "upset", I am suspicious. You're better than this Thea and your scumslips when they do come are subtle manipulations. The issues are: 1. That you presented your analysis of my role as my claim for the role. You are intentionally trying to obfuscate your role. I don't understand w...

@bessie

Sorry to hear about Hoku. My brother has a Labradoodle with health issues and has been feeding her frozen beans (presumably cooked first, then frozen so they're a bit crunchy), be worth a try.

I have to cool down my language because, that's genuinely so bad meta-wise. A BP had one purpose, to absorb NKs. After the full extent of a BP is already known, it can do nothing more useful. A one shot can't pull an important power, a full BP won't be targeted again or will just get strongmanned, ...

That's what you BELIEVE it is. That's not what I claimed. Which again brings up the question, what are you trying to pull? I'm not trying to pull anything. I'm working with the information that I have available to me. I think the deliberate ambiguity you are creating around your role is extremely s...

I made no such claim, what are you pulleding Thea? If you'd like to clarify your claim, you are welcome to do so. Based on what you've said so far, this is what your role appears to be. That's what you BELIEVE it is. That's not what I claimed. Which again brings up the question, what are you trying...

Adum's claim of one-shot BP looks like a huge outlier in this setup and I don't believe that he has no night actions of any sort. His play today has been very strange. I'm parking this read for now and I will try to come back to it later. I made no such claim, what are you pulleding Thea? If you'd ...

Somi/Wam stuff: town core in no particular order - Adum, Mak (tone as discussed already) - Fred, Thea (I'd probably scumread Fred in isolation, but I don't think there's a way mafia!Thea would do something as audacious and risky as claiming masons D1) high-probability town - Seven (clearing Adum) sc...

Sabrar wrote: ↑Tue Nov 19, 2024 3:58 pm 9 players alive and 6 to hammer (still not a typo)

This is still super weird.

Vote: moody I think moody and Santy are more or less the only people who I think make sense as partners to somi. Santy, actually, probably has the best reason to have killed JC in the night so I think that's somewhere that is worth following up on regardless of moody's flip. I think Wam is probably...

We elim bessie today. Mak is never wrong when he’s like this. Adum could you claim though? It would help with the paranoia. Why the pressure on Adum to claim? Suspicious. I know this is directed at Seven, but since I've been pushing this as well, I will say that I do not think there is any benefit ...

And also the no cop on n1, to cop the mason on n2 which didnt align with their approach from before, just because it was better "objectively" also hard to believe for myself Wam said a couple times that he was paranoid about me/Fred so I don't think this was an entirely unreasonable play....

Why? Assuming Adum was the NK target, then it is extremely unlikely that any other scum would bother using their powers on him. Wam evidently did use a power on Adum N1 since he knew the name of bessie's role, and it is obscure enough that the only way he likely could have got it correct is if eith...

It's a hell of a guess considering that multiple people had already claimed loud, and there was an extensive discussion about the cop being "loud" specifically, before Wam's claim. The only role that has this modifier, as currently claimed is bessie's. Wam's disengagement was a significan...

Why? Assuming Adum was the NK target, then it is extremely unlikely that any other scum would bother using their powers on him. Wam evidently did use a power on Adum N1 since he knew the name of bessie's role, and it is obscure enough that the only way he likely could have got it correct is if eith...

3) Wam did in fact use a Watcher power on Adum and is not part of the team that did the NK.

EWBOP

yes somi knew my exact role which is why I had zero doubt somis power claim was truthful and why I was ok eliming the slot over the suspicious choice of picking me and the provided rationale Thanks. I think this rules out a Wam/Somi pairing except in the exact combination where Mak is also mafia. W...

There is no fixing this paranoia. You both are full up on confirmation bias and adding increasingly unlikely attributes game attributes to make it work, then treating that the theory exists as proof that it's what happened without any mech or social evidence it's what happened. And yet you conspicu...

Motivating Loudener, but also how did you know my role? Interesting. So somi knew your specific role. yes somi knew my exact role which is why I had zero doubt somis power claim was truthful and why I was ok eliming the slot over the suspicious choice of picking me and the provided rationale Thanks...

Oops,.posted under my alt account. Sorry.

I would urge people to exercise restraint in clearing slots as being unable to kill based on claims of roleblocking. I would not be even remotely surprised if scum had a strongman and I'm surprised so many people are considering ninja without similarly considering strongman potential. Also not all ...

I'm a Role Cop, each night I can learn someone's role (but not their alignment). N1 I targeted Mak because I didn't catch his crumb I knew you were role cop which is why I included it in the known/anticipated role list. I don’t believe you though on why you targeted Mak. What is his role? Motivatin...

Scum has night chat only. Bessie doesn’t know the order of her sanities. She’s informed at the start of day what it was the previous night. Somi was communicating with her in that feeling paranoid post. I'd be surprised if scum has night chat only while we have both day and night chat. Like it's po...

Oh, Seven also has a roleblock on moody.

Thea - Mason (N1 - none, N2 Track Santy) Fred - Mason (N1- none, N2 Watch Wam) Seven - JoaT 1 (N1 cop on Adum, N2 parrot on bessie) Wam - JoaT 2 (N1 watch on Adum, N2 cop on Thea) JC - JoaT 3 (N1 track Seven or target Adum???, N2 target moody???) Moody - Backup (N1 inherit Traffic cop + ???, N2 role...