New XKCD Forums

In

Yeah as I said out of the hundred+ times it's been run it trends 55/45. I'd be interested in how you can nudge it if you have thoughts. No N0 for the seer is possible but I like town having some starting info. game probably doesnt need the martyr tbh? Its just a weaker doc and doc/cop together in a...

To be honest, this wasn't a very satisfying game to play as scum. I didn't get the opportunity to hunt for the sorcerer, and I believe the total number of DM's between me and Maven was under 10. I was trying really hard to push for J D2, but after Maven died it became abundantly clear that I did no...

ggs everyone, fun game! Setup def feels a little too town favored but all things considered I think that was just exaggerated by sorc getting elim'd right away glad my instincts weren't off on fred lol EGW was fun taking your hand to the promised land, good stuff town tapping it in, looking forward...

I think you were great and I wish we'd gotten to play more. You as well! You helped me alley oop on somi. It was such a good elimination and such a good and swift decision for us to fall onto somi. You said you thought I could emulate this, I'm not too sure I could but I was also going for less pos...

I was thinking Doop may have been scum with Bessie but actually Doop was the mvp for helping me switch from Bessie to Somi. I would have either way begrudingly. Apologies bessie, I misread your excitement and tone as forcing and emulation of your town game but I saw some of it (your town play from ...

heuristically_alone wrote: ↑Sat Aug 26, 2023 1:16 am We definitely lucked out hitting the sorcerer D1. Leans the game almost unfairly entirely in towns favor after that.

Yeah the set-up is super swingy. I love it but there's not a way around that if you want 11p and roles that aren't super weak.

I thought so. If anyone else was it they would have claimed it.

oh yeah now that it's pointless to hide it, I can illustrate that: ' S up e veryone. E xcited & r eady - this is my favorite setup and I'm so glad Seven decided to borrow it from when I ran it in 2020. E ven though I haven't played in years I should hopefully have not lost my touch too much. R ...

The really is no reason to kill Bessie unless we truly dont get a replacement/counter claim. Seven should provide a chance for that slot to claim before it becomes necessary. Did Bessie see the crumb and that's why she targeted doop? Not possible. Her investigation was a N0, before I made the claim.

oh yeah now that it's pointless to hide it, I can illustrate that: ' S up e veryone. E xcited & r eady - this is my favorite setup and I'm so glad Seven decided to borrow it from when I ran it in 2020. E ven though I haven't played in years I should hopefully have not lost my touch too much. R a...

I mean it doesn't matter which one you choose, but that we know your choice does matter. Moody can choose from my point-of-view he is totally confirmed town. And I’m not getting counterclaimed by J. That sounded ominous lol Statement of fact. It would be playing against his win condition which is n...

Also you'd be insane to propose a game-locking plan as the last Wolf so it's really down to Fred/Huery. J is conftown because he's either seer cleared or the Seer. In the latter case, because both he and Bessie agree he's town, there's no 50/50. If he claims Seer he must be the real Seer and we imme...

You are correct that it's technically better to drag this out, and I genuinely respect that, but I just can't be arsed to. The odds we don't win are vanishingly small and if we somehow lose that way it would be hilarious and well played by the last Wolf

Even that's not too disastrous. If Scum kill Bessie tonight then the Hunter has another day to set the vengeful. If Scum kill the Hunter then we get another Bessie read.

The only bad scenario is hunter kill killing Bessie which should not be possible (even J was here after the Seer claim).

But we can spill his guts

Ok cool let's murder Fred

AdumbroDeus wrote: ↑Thu Aug 24, 2023 5:06 am

bessie wrote: ↑Thu Aug 24, 2023 4:48 am I hate claiming but no reason to waste half a day.

I investigated Prince J.
bessie and Prince J.PNG

That means werewolf right?

Oh wait I thought Bessie was the dog and J was the human giving pats.

Actually, I'm pretty sure this game is effectively over mathmaticly. Either Bessie is seer and Prince J is town, which means 4 of 7 spots are cleared and we have a guaranteed at least 3 town kills left between hunter and lynches. Hunter just has to target whichever of the 3 unconfirmed folks (mysel...

*that's where the wolf is

I would've rathered Mak didn't claim because Bessie already announced their target and it wasn't Mak. Plus we were still waiting on two claims. Technically that was twilight. But ya, we're waiting on Bessie and J at the moment, if J counterclaims it's GG cause there's only one scum left. Just pure ...

1. EGW - Vanilla
2. PJ
3. Adum
4. somi - Sorcerer
5. heury
6. bessie - Seer
7. Mak - Martyr
8. Fred
9. Maven - Werewolf
10. moody - Seer Clear
11. Dooplisity - Seer Clear

gg egw time to find out if we have a cc for bessie: 1. EGW - Vanilla 2. PJ 3. Adum 4. somi - Sorcerer 5. heury 6. bessie - Seer 7. Mak - Martyr 8. Fred 9. Maven - Werewolf 10. moody - Seer Clear 11. Dooplisity - Seer Clear y'all don't need to claim what you are, just if you're the seer or not

Godspeed Mak o7

So at this point even though we haven't heard from J we can assume Bessie is the seer - if J CCs her then we win automatically and it's gg.

Hunter should stay quiet because we win if we can get them to endgame and Bessie isn't getting another read anyway.