New XKCD Forums

I meant to add a ping to seven in the above post but eh. I asked you about this before, but to reiterate, Wam claims that they got an answer that "publishing cop" is the rolename. Could you verify that you can also get the same information? I already asked the mods 4 questions and I’m too...

I meant to add a ping to seven in the above post but eh.

Seven wrote: ↑Thu Nov 21, 2024 4:01 am

I asked you about this before, but to reiterate, Wam claims that they got an answer that "publishing cop" is the rolename. Could you verify that you can also get the same information?

3) publishing cop is the role, madge thought it's a separate role in the wiki but it's not as far as I can see. This seems wrong to me. Like, Madge discussing a role or giving out this information to the person that doesn’t have the role. It seems like a breach of Mod duty that I wouldn’t expect he...

On the you versus Thea thing, I've played with bessie long enough to think you being cagey about your role is not AI, but I can totally see Thea's point about wanting you to lay cards on the table at this stage in the game. That was not in fact what me versus Thea was about. It wasn't Thea asking y...

moody7277 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 21, 2024 2:11 am On the you versus Thea thing, I've played with bessie long enough to think you being cagey about your role is not AI, but I can totally see Thea's point about wanting you to lay cards on the table at this stage in the game.

That was not in fact what me versus Thea was about.

moody7277 wrote: ↑Wed Nov 20, 2024 1:57 am

*Ping*

Do you have anything to contribute?

Didn't ask adum I will now Please do, if it doesn't... I hate to admit it but seven's plan may be just *gulp* better. Im dumb and forgot that the mafia factional NK is explicity excluded from being affected by my ability It is silent on indy or other non-faction kill killing roles and the modes wil...

bessie wrote: ↑Wed Nov 20, 2024 6:50 am

Question, what's your sanity gonna be this night phase? N3 I mean.

You cant be a liability in yeet or lose as long as you are always trying to solve and push for our win if town. You are a liability if you selfvote and makes us waste a valuable yeet on yourself just as an attempt for your read to be more valued No Mak is right. Town has lost a lot due to the wrong...

Makhaira wrote: ↑Wed Nov 20, 2024 8:32 pm Didn't ask adum I will now

Please do, if it doesn't... I hate to admit it but seven's plan may be just *gulp* better.

@Santy: I want to eliminate non-Wam scum today because I want to use his loud abilities tonight. Additionally, if Adum is indeed 3P, then it may be that he is trying to off the JOATs. What use do they have? Like, Mak does have them loud for today to confirm what they do but thats about it? You thin...

But whatever

unvote

I'll slide in as a spiritual vote on moody because the play I'm trying to make just clearly isn't happening and we aren't killing Wam clearly either.

Which really just shows how much of a Cassandra I am.

Adum, the reason why Thea and I are trying to figure out the different ways you can be scum isn’t that we are in lala theorycrafting land, it’s that you’re really just quite suspicious, and it doesn’t line up with the “town” result. I’ll case in full all the things I find suspicious later. It's not...

Could you just vote me please? You'll learn a lot from my yeet, if I chicken out you'll know it was a self-pres Gambit and that I'm scum anyway, and if I do end up flipping scum you'll know I was trying to protect moody. Same to you Mak, if you think this is an ATE, call my bluff. And yes, I fully ...

I am not "upset", I am suspicious. You're better than this Thea and your scumslips when they do come are subtle manipulations. The issues are: 1. That you presented your analysis of my role as my claim for the role. You are intentionally trying to obfuscate your role. I don't understand w...

Seven wrote: ↑Wed Nov 20, 2024 2:05 pm

Oh ya, and please ask Wam's question to verify if you haven't already. Thanks.

Adum, the reason why Thea and I are trying to figure out the different ways you can be scum isn’t that we are in lala theorycrafting land, it’s that you’re really just quite suspicious, and it doesn’t line up with the “town” result. I’ll case in full all the things I find suspicious later. It's not...

Anyways, if it comes down to moody or Wam, my choice is and continues to be Wam. I'm kind of in a POE spot for moody because the only significant thing that pinged me is his response to Mak which seemed legit but it could've just been "you're another scum faction/Indy" reaction. Their rati...

Well, technically the entire thing is the role name but what part is the "core" role's name that a role observe would see and what part is ancillary modifiers.

Tbh, I feel that this type of talk is exactly why answering hypothetical are a good thing from a puzzle aspect.

Ok, that's fair, I'd appreciate you asking Bessie, even though I genuinely don't understand how it's possible to interpret it as part of the role name rather than a modifier on the role.

Agree to disagree dawg but all your reactions this game have been outsized and you're picking weird fights over nothingburgers with strong towncore candidates which makes me think you're less focused on solving and more focused on something unique to your POV which feels informed or otherwise motiv...

"self-prez", that's a funny way to classify self-voting and saying please kill me and when you stop being paranoid do what I say with a side of "ok kill my target and if I'm wrong I'll let you kill me". That's genuinely an odd way to classify how I'm playing right now. its overl...

"self-prez", that's a funny way to classify self-voting and saying please kill me and when you stop being paranoid do what I say with a side of "ok kill my target and if I'm wrong I'll let you kill me".

That's genuinely an odd way to classify how I'm playing right now.

bessie wrote: ↑Wed Nov 20, 2024 3:42 am Hoku went to the vet and he failed his blood test and his ultrasound test and she put him on a vegetarian diet. I have no idea what we’re going to feed him tonight.

I'm sorry! I hope Hoku is ok soon!

Unfortunately I don't have any advice to offer

Also the loud bit doesn't come up on the day start Post it's " JOAT targeted x" And? Loud roles consistently don't get modifiers when they're named in beginning of day posts, that's consistent. We just saw flips get modifiers. The issue is that your claim is inconsistent. It caught the pu...