New XKCD Forums

Mak, I'm happy to see you asking some good questions here and redirect people to Santy. People dismissing them so quickly really makes me regret voting Heury. Honestly I'm not for killing someone to be able to look at two wagon results, because I don't see anyone really even going over a vote analy...

Thea: I genuinely thought you were referring to the Seven V EGW comment from Somi. Also I wasn't defending him, still. I struggle to read him soon enough, but then when he doesn't post reasonable content he is readable to me. That's why it took longer to realize. I wasn't pushing you on it, I was k...

Congrats Heury.

I appreciate you Mak.

I am town. Wish you were around more so we could have talked reads more.

If in doubt, flip Somi next phase. He is for sure a hit.

Just vote.

If Heury flips town, Somi + Seven are scum.

Vote Somi.

I am curious what you are thinking at this moment, Thea.

Question to others with better knowledge of Mak's schedule/style/etc: do you think I'm likely to get a vote-instruction from Mak? At the moment I'm inclined to vote Heury. Mak plays WoW / Raids consistently. He's pretty busy, and works alot. I forget the actual schedule though. Also Somi did not re...

somi is possible, but I think his recent post about waiting to be replaced if he's going to be yeeted for info makes it unlikely. I have not read into that. I'm just basing my read on his content. What concerns me about your slot is that your Somi read moves from too wolfy to be wolf to town for a ...

Freddino18 wrote: ↑Thu Sep 12, 2024 9:03 pmGonna Vote: Heury

Please explain why, and give me your thoughts on Somi.

I feel like you are mafia here and your only option at this juncture is to push Huery. However, please give our what you state is the difference between Heurys scum and town play.

I think your reasoning for me is weak. There have been times you and I disagreed on reads as a hydra and then we came together to find mafia anyway. I do actually take stock into shroops because I saw it work two times when I pushed against it, looking like an idiot each time.

I do too, but looking at the votes I think it's best we just switch to somi. The more I push for heury, the more George & Alli are going to be thinking I'm attempting to save somi, and therefore locked into the somi wagon. Vote: somi What did you take away from me linking Baldur's Gate to you i...

moody7277 wrote: ↑Thu Sep 12, 2024 2:41 amWas that an accident, or did you intentionally reference the cherry tree story.

I have no idea what the cherry tree story is but I wish I did now.

I will not, as it contains references to my own role and I do not want to scrub the whole document to remove those. Why does your process to generate a scum list contain references to your own role? Just post the parts that do not contain those references. I put this process off as long as I can ea...

Agreed with JC. Seven, I like it when you call me George honestly.

I'll do Somi next @Ran. The reason why I haven't already is because I've done so in prior games and found no differences. As Alli said, he has both good and bad games both as town and scum, and they are indistinguishable from content alone. Eliminating him early on is pure chance, and I prefer to r...

And this !!!! Is because Seven assumed that EGW would scumread him for his early push and somi wasn't following the thread but just what was being said in scumchat. Yes that was very weird. I discounted it at first as just him not reading but what you say makes more sense. Also the vote on Seven wa...

Theallieza wrote: ↑Wed Sep 11, 2024 9:19 pmWhy do you think moody is Town?

I just didn't really get any pings from him, and I see a high post volume from him. That's honestly it though, I usually struggle reading him. Walk me through your read on him again please.