New XKCD Forums

It's because of all the swag I've accumulated from DGames. He couldn't resist it

Hello! I'm up for this.

Players
1. Heury
2. Wam
3. bessie
4. Makhaira
5. Eido
6.
7.
8.
9.

Good game! You guys are very fun.

Thank you Laser for hosting.

And you too, Barry. There is no way a bee should be able to fly.

Right but Somi just comes in and disappears. And Boom tries to swing to Somi at one point, with Somi not being online to save himself. It doesn't look like cooperation to me there

My head's thinking about you or Mak. It comes mainly down to POE. I don't think it's going to be Somi based on his EOD1 votes and the way the Night kills have happened, and overall think it's unlikely to be Phillip based on just gut really. Like the way he's so transparent with not knowing what to ...

@Messie: are you saying two separate things have happened to you? Vote: Makhaira I'll try and be here before deadline. I'm thinking Scum!Boom might have distanced from his buddy for Town points. He knew he was in danger of the yeet after D1, so probably had a chat with his buddy during the night abo...

Slammed at work at the mo so will probs have to jump online later on tonight. My head's thinking about you or Mak. It comes mainly down to POE. I don't think it's going to be Somi based on his EOD1 votes and the way the Night kills have happened, and overall think it's unlikely to be Phillip based o...

Yo Wam I keep coming back to this post. So it's been a long day and I had to read booms case a couple of times. I find the team analysis a bit winey but I say that about most team analysis. No self analysis as well I could argue for quite a few teams with boom in. ;) On the Makhira analysis that doe...

im glad you brought up this interaction though between me and boom because this should make it clear as day to everyone that I legitimately did not trust boom and thought he was trying to dodge me. me vs. boom would never have been a thing if I hadn't made such a big deal over the way boom handled ...

Yo @Makhaira you able to revisit this post for me? https://ramenchef.net/nxf/viewtopic.php?p=19910#p19910 Eido, you didn’t reply to this . Please answer. Yeah, so my question came really from our chat here: They made a post in the Night. Scum!Phillip is probably somewhat aware of the boundaries of t...

Ok so, I’ve been thinking about the choice of night kill. It could be argued Mark & myself have occupied a really similar spot this game. We’ve both been widely considered Town, and by D2 have had similar reads/votes. I feel like scum could categorise us similarly in the group chat as a result o...

Just a heads up to say I've been rereading the thread. Will post thoughts later

I don't think it's Somi: shady messie: kind of odd that I'm so high on her list with a "not much" after getting one of her two fingers of suspicion. Heury: feels less easygoing than usual to me, but it's hardly condemning BoomFrog: some early-game weirdness and his read on Eido (and to a l...

Gonna try speed post some bits The movements look all over the place. Wam’s EOD post looks he’s written it with a gun to his head. It’s weird. Boom voting Wam, and then joining Wam on his Makhaira vote is weird. Boom's content is very scatty, from A to B to C. I still think there's a chance this con...

I’m here. On phone so it will be hard.

Still undecided about somitomi. Just feels like they haven't had time to pay much attention to the game. same boomfrog undermining my TMI bait and now 180ing and saying he town reads me for it feels gross, like he's cutting bait and running fine with boom or heury going at this point. wouldnt be up...

Can you link to the content where BoomFrog says (or alludes to) this? Because I don’t see it. It comes from Boom's explanation here: https://ramenchef.net/nxf/viewtopic.php?p=19445#p19445 For your other question, I haven't been thinking about that. I don't really know. How are you planning to solve...

This is frustrating because there's a lot of context that only half the players here have. Most of my recent games D1 I have done a "gambit", something intentionally "anti-town" on it's surface to provoke reactions. It's been one of the most successful ways I have to get good re...

They made a post in the Night. Scum!Phillip is probably somewhat aware of the boundaries of the game, considering they have Osie as a mentor. If the scum plan is resorting to dirty tactics like encouraging Phillip to fake a Night post, I think the team gets scolded by Osie (who is big on the ethics ...

@Wam If you're online, can you take me through how you're seeing Messie right now?

My head’s somewhere here: Mark / Phillip Wam / Makhaira / Messie Somi / Boom Aside from the Night kill trail, my issue with Boom is that he was aware low effort players likelier contain scum, but spent most of his time D1 looking to undermine high effort posters instead. It's not clear if his push o...

shady messie: kind of odd that I'm so high on her list with a "not much" after getting one of her two fingers of suspicion. Heury: feels less easygoing than usual to me, but it's hardly condemning BoomFrog: some early-game weirdness and his read on Eido (and to a lesser extent Sabrar) jus...

I got burned badly last game by Osie and decided my D1 mission was to get a read on the high effort players. If the low effort players contain the scum then I trust the surviving high effort players to suss them out on later days. This is unclear. Why didn't you spend more time yesterDay looking in...

Do you not think Sabrar publicly implying that he expects to be night eliminated by BoomFrog would give any scum player a motive to kill Sabrar, not just BoomFrog? Hm yes it's possible. But it feels quite niche if this was the only motive at this time. Scum might be likelier to look at a player's i...

@Messie @Somi Oh, sorry, the thread had died so I felt like voting. I wasn't thinking about scum rushing in to kill Town!Boom. The thread is picking up so I'll be more mindful of activity.

Need to read.