New XKCD Forums

osieorb18 wrote: ↑Mon Feb 14, 2022 11:42 pm
You know some of them.

I know now more than enough

I would add i understood the role i received is made by you and I don't know how come the townie voting me didn't get such a simple thing because you almost said it.

Your initial plan was to ML him and it was so transparent.

Osie well played you convinced me in day 1 the worst needs time and that was my fault. He was pure scum and I let myself fooled I knew Bessie can't be scum and I was paranoid of Madge. That was another mistake i made I came to the truth and i am sure a player who knows me would understand me. My lan...

You don't know how the role works. That's a lie. Remember the setup. Of course I know how the role works. You talk about alien stuff but i never mentioned that, you invent things. An Alien is a type of Jailkeeper. Look, i have a number of gifts I couldn't give you a gift last night but I received b...

I'm pretty sure I know how WMU's role works and what she's described is impossible... Sniper still looks the most sus, but WMU's claim is pretty bad. I kinda like Madge's claim and following behaviour. Also this claim is a mess. Why so? It shows you lied so of course you will brush it off I know ho...

I think your scumread on me is less that I've made a bad claim and more that I haven't actually made a full claim yet. I should probably come out and say that I'm an absorber. Any ability that targets me, I get a one-shot of that ability for future nights. I got a lookout one-shot N1 (which was err...

Voting for me will loose town the game because I am town and my full claim is accurate. Vote Osie You don't know how the role works. That's a lie. You didn't receive my gift last night You talk about alien stuff but i never mentioned that, you invent things. When i accused you you turned against me ...

osieorb18 wrote: ↑Mon Feb 14, 2022 8:36 am I'm pretty sure I know how WMU's role works and what she's described is impossible...

Sniper still looks the most sus, but WMU's claim is pretty bad.

I kinda like Madge's claim and following behaviour.

Why is Sniper sus?

I have literally been scumhunting all game. Like all I have been doing is pressing people asking questions discussing things and giving my reads. This is how I scumhunt. Suspect me if you need to but "hasn't scumhunted all game" is patently false - ive been scumhunting for the entire game...

My role gives gifts for dead or alive. I understood wrong that i will receive something from the targeted player role and N1 I targeted Moody with a gift. I received the same gift back N2. I targeted Osie last night and my action failed. Because of what i received, i wasn't RBed. But for the action...

So i am alive because I had bad reads and votes. That doesn't mean I am scum, that means I am pocketed by scum and I have wrong reads. Now thinking at day 1, Osie used his meta knowledge to tell me the worst is villager. After so many flips and after the worst who wasn't suspected by others except m...

I feel like this setup is going to be hilarious once all is revealed Oh absolutely. My votes are on WMU and the worst. I'm not too stressed yet, but your solve isn't 2/2. we're pretty close to the wire, and town voting incorrectly is going to cost us the game. Not saying you need to bend your reads...

My role gives gifts for dead or alive. I understood wrong that i will receive something from the targeted player role and N1 I targeted Moody with a gift. I received the same gift back N2. I targeted Osie last night and my action failed. Because of what i received, i wasn't RBed. But for the action ...

Well i read it now though, what is curious is not only the clear of Madge without conviction, there are implied accusations. What wasn't quoted by Osie is the claimed vote on me who are not explained. By the way, given that bessie saw madge visit osie N2 and he very clearly isn't dead, I think we ca...

Osie i think you put in words a thought i had.

I will read though the spoiler in the morning and share my ideas

Are the votes locked? Is midnight for me, I will think and post more tomorow I wish to point out that Heury flipping tracker/watcher/role cop means that probably town doesn't have another similar role, so Madge's claim sticks out as fake for me. Idk what to do with Snade's claim. Is claiming allowed?

Vote Heury

I hope he flips scum. if he flips town i will reset all my reads

I hope I am right in suspecting Heury, I keep thinking at this silence and I don't like it at all.

I will post my vote in 15 mins

No one is here?

Why is here is no interaction at Eod?

Reading in Boomfrog's Iso I understand he town read Bessie.

Thanks for the VC

Bessie's vote is L-1, right?

Heury please post your games mistakes. I won't search for them . The 2 posts i quoted contradict each other, in the first you say both should be town in the second you say both are scummy. And now you only vote to self press but you find a reason in the fact Osie is towny. Do you disagree that Osie...

Is thrawn a claim who is proving something?