New XKCD Forums

I would have to know the claim. I go 50/50. I come up with some crazy gambits and know how to buy a day or two. He probably would have been better with a UB claim rather than target the dead. Then could have gotten Sabrar’s power and lurky ness makes more sense

Sorry again. At least Sabrar and Marklin were good scumreads I had a sus on Madge then lost it then when trying to explain Ducky town I accidentally locked Madge as a townread. And apologies to Seven for scumreading you so hard. I am surprised you didn’t go down for claiming scum at the tail end of ...

At least killing me resulted in scum losing like I thought

Sorry for hard clearing Madge. I thought for a threat to be eliminated you had to have a player around definitionally so I hard cleared Madge.

Parity usually works because then you can just kill the remaining players but here in this hyperliteral case because of how it’s written scum if Ducky/Madge auto lose.

You win when no threats to mafia remain or nothing can prevent this from occurring.

A Townie is still a threat. Ducky and Madge if scum can’t eliminate all townies and therefore would lose.

It would be interesting if I was a mafia traitor and hammered to give WMU another day. It would be since you spent all day poking at Madge then put yourself on moody to “get rid of the block” Yet if Madge or Ducky are scum they can’t win if they are lovers. Elo would be Madge + Ducky + 1 player. El...

Conf town at EoD: Madge, worst, Jedi (via worst) Should be conf: MathBlade (saving now confirmed town) Scum is WMU+Seven like I said and will be taking a gamble. If I am wrong (worse case scenario) then Jedi, Wam, WMU+Seven, Me We elim whoever of WMU/Seven I didn’t block and should be GG get wrecked...

So either Moody is lying about lovers in which case probably mafia and we win or scum have two conf town on their hands

Mechanical PoE then is Wam/myself/WMU/Seven.

All I had to do for town to win is not be elimmed today because I highly suspect that’s a true claim it’s a matter of which is which.

It would be interesting if I was a mafia traitor and hammered to give WMU another day. It would be since you spent all day poking at Madge then put yourself on moody to “get rid of the block” Yet if Madge or Ducky are scum they can’t win if they are lovers. Elo would be Madge + Ducky + 1 player. El...

I read it twice and I'm p sure a mutual friend of mathb's and mine has introduced you to moonlogic. Madge, if scum, also needs to produce clears until she has PoE'd herself. There's one thing in particular which you aren't seeing that I won't be explaining before d4. Vote: Moody Quack. Will comprom...

I'm fine with a massclaim btw. I'm like a tracker person. It's kind of hard to use though so I kind of forked up both nights. It works as so: If the first person I vote is also the last person I vote, I am told if they visit any people that I have voted between them, or myself during the night. I a...

I can finally play, sorry i was busy in the morning. @Steven, I have few hours to read and check my opinion on Moody About Math's tone, I don't like it, he looks like he is in a hurry to push me and wants to attract the others in this push. He is completely disregarding my claim and he wants detail...

Why the fuck was Madge wagoned? It’s WMU and plus or minus seven. Mass claim should be happening. We have a majority of us claimed. And if Madge dies it’s a scum claim back off. Both Madge and I are invests: Elim is WMU / Moody. WMU is most likely as doc claim is bullshit but would compromise on Moo...

32 hours and the thread is dead.... Thread is dead because people are voting me because they don’t like my play, not that they think I am scum. Was AFK taking care of my mom and will be afk with work/nap. WMU+Seven last reads. Good luck. WMU scum claimed by not announcing targets because he’s not a...

So Math wants to kill the town protective because this is his 'hunch' and he doesn't really care about anything else. He is not concerned about the possible existence of a strongman who would cancel his clears, even if he is mentioning it And you know why? Because he knows strongman doesn't exist a...

@math why bit scum dicky being blocked on whatever power they have and scum marklin does the kill? I dont get yournducky clear? Because blocking isn’t confirmable. I don’t know if I succeed. Redirection, roleblock on me, jailkeep on me, another scum claims to have to sheep me. There are so many way...

If scum Duck didn’t confirm I blocked him then no. It’s not necessarily thunderdome. I could have been blocked or redirected. It would be suspicious not lock scum.

I prefer not to spend time on theories that I do not see possible.

The moment I flip town the worst is confirmed town to you as Ducky can’t kill.

The simple answer is that scum reside in WMU or WMU and you.

The doctor claim is sus and without who protected as town protects me who CC’d you or Bessie.

The more reasonable explanation is people can multitask rather than my literal interpretation (thanks Wam). The worst did not kill because I blocked him. This is town Ducky. Therefore if you want to assume worst scum it has to be with Marklin. Therefore in a world where you believe it’s me+Worst you...

That confirms Morgan couldn’t do the kill.

It was the Block AND that he confirmed me as a roleblocker. That’s always been my point. Ducky as scum does not confirm that I blocked him.

Vote: WMU

Just in case prior didn’t take.
Let’s gooooooo!

Wam and moody are cleared as they would have hammered me. It’s WMU and maybe traitor Seven. Or Seven is the strongman/ascetic because I was too heavy handed. Why it's not mylo or lylo? I said I suspected Seven EoD yesterday. They could have easily strongmanned or been ascetic and forgot the sheep p...

Wam and moody are cleared as they would have hammered me. It’s WMU and maybe traitor Seven. Or Seven is the strongman/ascetic because I was too heavy handed.

Wam wrote: ↑Tue Dec 07, 2021 4:37 pm I took that as each phase each player can do one factional and one non factional action.

Maybe it will get changed before the next game but that’s not how I took it but yay hyper literal. :/

Can we just do WMU please?

I am paranoid about them. That’s all you need right? *glares at Madge*